Skip to Content

Reading Primary Sources

The Interpretation of Texts from Nineteenth and Twentieth Century History

Edited by Miriam Dobson, Benjamin Ziemann

Published July 17th 2008 by Routledge – 10 pages

Series: Routledge Guides to Using Historical Sources

Purchasing Options:

Description

How does the historian approach primary sources? How do interpretations differ? How can they be used to write history?

Reading Primary Sources goes a long way to providing answers for these questions. In the first part of this unique volume, the chapters give an overview of both traditional and new methodological approaches to the use of sources, analyzing the way that these have changed over time. The second part gives an overview of twelve different types of written sources, including letters, opinion polls, surveillance reports, diaries, novels, newspapers, and dreams, taking into account the huge expansion in the range of written primary sources used by historians over the last thirty years. This book is an up-to-date introduction into the historical context of these different genres, the ways they should be read, the possible insights and results these sources offer and the pitfalls of their interpretation. All of the chapters push the reader beyond a conventional understanding of source texts as mere "reflections" of a given reality, instead fostering an understanding of how each of the various genres has to be seen as a medium in its own right.

Taking examples of sources from around the globe, and also including a student-friendly further reading section, this is the perfect companion for every student of history who wants to engage with sources.

Reviews

‘The chapters always have a clear structure; their great merit is that they all follow the agenda laid out by the editors in a ‘basic checklist’ in their introduction and thus have a similar, unified structure … All in all, this volume can convince. It introduces the problem of the literary qualities of primary source texts in a manner that can be found nowhere else.’ – Stefan Jordan, H-Soz-u-Kult

Contents

Acknowledgments. List of Contributors. List of Abbreviations Part 1: Reading Primary Sources: Contexts and Approaches 1. Reading Primary Sources. An Introduction Benjamin Ziemann/Miriam Dobson 2. Understanding History. Hermeneutics and Source Criticism in Historical Scholarship Philipp Müller 3. Reading Texts after the Linguistic Turn. Approaches from Literary Studies and their Implications Christoph Reinfandt Part 2: Varieties of Primary Sources and their Interpretation 1. Letters Miriam Dobson 2. Surveillance Reports Moritz Föllmer 3. Court Files Claudia Verhoeven 4. Opinion Polls Anja Kruke 5. Memoranda Kristina Spohr Readman 6. Diaries Christa Hämmerle, translated by Andrew Evans 7. Novels Julia Reid 8. Autobiography David Carlson 9. Newspapers Stephen Vella 10. Speeches Paul Readman 11. Testimony Devin Pendas. Glossary

Author Bio

Miriam Dobson is Lecturer in Modern History at the University of Sheffield. Her forthcoming monograph explores popular responses to the reforms of the Khrushchev era.

Benjamin Ziemann is Reader in Modern History at the University of Sheffield. His recent publications include: War Experiences in Rural Germany 1914-1923 (2007), and Peace Movements in Western Europe, Japan and the USA during the Cold War (2007).

Download

‘The chapters always have a clear structure; their great merit is that they all follow the agenda laid out by the editors in a ‘basic checklist’ in their introduction and thus have a similar, unified structure … All in all, this volume can convince. It introduces the problem of the literary qualities of primary source texts in a manner that can be found nowhere else.’ – Stefan Jordan, H-Soz-u-Kult
Read the Full Review (in German)

Download the Endorsements (pdf)

Available on the Apple iBookstore

Name: Reading Primary Sources: The Interpretation of Texts from Nineteenth and Twentieth Century History (Paperback) – Routledge 
Description: Edited by Miriam Dobson, Benjamin Ziemann. How does the historian approach primary sources? How do interpretations differ? How can they be used to write history? Reading Primary Sources goes a long way to providing answers for these questions. In the first part of this unique volume, the...
Categories: Modern History 1750-1945, History: Theory, Method & Historiography, History