Reappraising State-Owned Enterprise
A Comparison of the UK and Italy
Edited by Franco Amatori, Robert Millward, Pier Angelo Toninelli
Routledge – 2011 – 286 pages
Routledge – 2011 – 286 pages
After a quarter century of almost general condemnation and rebuttal of the entire nationalization experience, it appears that there are second thoughts about governmental direct intervention in the economy. Reappraising State-Owned Enterprise deals with a topic often undervalued in the past decade but which now, with the crisis of 2008-2009, calls for greater attention: the direct intervention of the State as Entrepreneur.
The collection of essays in this volume – prepared by some of the leading authorities in the field – offers a contribution to this debate by providing a balanced assessment of two of the most relevant experiences of mixed economies, the United Kingdom and Italy. In this respect, a comparison between these two countries is very much appropriate since in both nations the State played an important role as "Entrepreneur" starting in the early 20th century. In Great Britain and Italy, the heyday of the "State as Entrepreneur" was in the years right after WWII when it was used as a tool for promoting a modern society in which citizens acquired a stronger sense of belonging to their nations.
The UK and Italy saw the State take on a too-pervasive role in the 70s; the two nations responded in different ways. In the 1980s Great Britain embarked on a harsh process of privatizations while Italians struggled on until finally submitting to privatizations in their nation in the following decade. The deep crisis of the final years of the 21st century forced both nations to reconsider State interventions as an appropriate tool in order to protect the wellbeing of the national economy.
Part I: Policies, Outcomes and Funding 1. Introduction. Franco Amatori, Robert Millward and Pierangelo Toninelli 2. The Nature of State Enterprise in Britain. Robert Millward 3. Does a Model of Italian State-Owned Enterprise Really Exist? Franco Amatori and Pierangelo Toninelli 4. Attempts To ‘Modernize’: Nationalization and the Nationalized Industries in Post-War Britain. Glen O’Hara 5. Size, Boundaries and Distribution of Italian State-Owned Enterprise (1939-1983). Pierangelo Toninelli and Michelangelo Vasta 6. The Financing of a Large Infrastructure Project: The Case of the Channel Tunnel. Terry Gourvish 7. Finance and Structure of the State-Owned Enterprise in Italy: Iri from the Golden Age To the Fall. Leandro Conte and Giandomenico Piluso Part II: State Owned Enterprises in Different Sectors 8. Property Rights, Economic Rents, BNOC and North Sea Oil. Martin Chick 9. Capabilities, Entrepreneurship and Political Direction in the Italian National Oil Company: AGIP/ENI 1926–1971. Daniele Pozzi 10. Iron and Steel State Industry in UK and Italy. Ruggero Ranieri 11. From Craftsmanship to Post-Fordism: Shipbuilding in the United Kingdom and Italy after WWII. Giulio Mellinato 12. State Enterprise in British Electricity Supply: An Economic Success? Robert Millward 13. Industrial Policy and the Nationalisation of the Italian Electricity Sector in the Post World War II Period. Renato Giannetti
Franco Amatori is Professor of Economic History as well as director of the Institute of the same at Bocconi University. His research interest in business history covers both Italian as well as international cases. He has published extensively including Big Business and the Wealth of Nations (co-editor with A. D. Chandler and Takashi Hikino, 1997) and Business History around the World (co-edited with Geoffrey Jones, 2003).
Robert Millward is has been Professor of Economic History at the University of Manchester, UK, since 1989 and Professor Emeritus since 2005. Recent research has focused on Europe’s infrastructure industries and its demography, as in his contribution to the new Cambridge Economic History of Modern Europe (ed. Broadberry and O’Rourke, 2010) and his own book, Private and Public Enterprise in Europe: Energy, Telecommunications and Transport: 1830-1990, 2005.
Pier Angelo Toninelli is Professor of Contemporary and Business History at the Department of Economics of the University of Milano-Bicocca. He has published extensively on the history of state-owned enterprise, of accounting, of comparative economic growth and entrepreneurship. He has just edited the volume The Determinants of Entrepreneurship: Leadership, Culture, Institutions (with J.L. Garcia-Ruiz, 2010).