I Like A Clamour: John Walpole Willis, Colonial Judge, Reconsidered, 1st Edition (Hardback) book cover

I Like A Clamour

John Walpole Willis, Colonial Judge, Reconsidered, 1st Edition

By Max Bonnell

Federation Press

304 pages

Purchasing Options:$ = USD

The Taylor & Francis Group cannot sell Federation Press products in your shipping region. For more information, please visit the Federation Press website.

FREE Standard Shipping!


The controversial career of John Walpole Willis is re-evaluated in the first comprehensive study of his legal career. Willis, the fifth judge to be appointed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, served in three colonies, and in each place he wrestled with the role of the law in a rapidly-changing society. In Upper Canada, he confronted the colony's transition from an oligarchy into a nascent democracy; in his next posting, in British Guyana, he was responsible for helping the colony implement, and absorb the consequences of, the abolition of slavery. New South Wales, his final posting, presented unique legal problems as it evolved from a penal colony into a free settlement, and the new settlement at Port Phillip began to grow.

To these troubled societies, Judge Willis brought an acute legal mind and a stormy personality – he was twice dismissed from his post by the local Governor. Earlier studies have tended to view him either as a wronged genius or a vain, deranged misfit. Max Bonnell, an experienced lawyer and Adjunct Professor of Law at Sydney University, has rediscovered Willis as a contradictory figure – Australia's first activist judge, who was nonetheless a stickler for the letter of the law; the author of several remarkably humane and enlightened judgments, who was capable of endorsing appalling cruelty; and a man who insisted upon decorum and propriety, yet was undone by his own conspicuous failures of self-control.


This is a rather remarkable book about a rather remarkable judge. Walpole Willis was a judge in the colony of New South Wales in the first half of the 19th century. By all accounts he was a person of an irascible nature but with an acute legal mind. He appears to have had considerable legal ability, albeit, at times, applied to the extreme. That was especially evident in his penchant for declaring the invalidity of the actions of his brother judges. He was a person of great humanity which was unfashionable for the times, but also known to be capable of great cruelty. Some described him as a wronged genius, others as a vain, deranged misfit.

Willis had an unusual legal career as a judge. He was appointed to three colonial courts, the last being in New South Wales. He was twice dismissed from office by the local Governor. In this work Max Bonnell has sought to unravel the mystery around this unusual and often contradictory judge. As Mr Bonnell identifies, Judge Willis’ judicial career spanned many difficult geographical locations where the system of justice was often just embryonic and social and political climate was in a state of constant flux. Nevertheless, it was not surprising that a judge who reportedly engaged in haranguing counsel, other judges, politicians and the press from the Bench, soon came into conflict with almost everybody wherever he was posted.

This an extremely well written book. It is well researched and carefully curated. The historical content is detailed but not cumbersome. Moreover, it is an important reminder of the human qualities of judges; that they possess the fragilities that we all do, to a greater or lesser degree, and they are often called upon to perform their duties in difficult political and social situations. This work is another excellent contribution to the chronicling of Australian Legal History, of which the Federation Press leads and champions.

Queensland Law Reporter – 24 February 2017 – [2017] 07 QLR

Table of Contents


“Dramatis Personae”

List of Illustrations

Introduction: Grimaces on the bench

1. Great disrespect and insult

2. The satisfaction of a gentleman

3. An attachment to Lady Mary

4. It is intended to commit that Jurisdiction to Mr Willis

5. You have not got your Equity Court yet

6. I dare say his Object will appear

7. An inferior situation

8. Little Insects

9. Dissolved, annulled, vacated and made void

10. No unfriendly feelings

11. We cannot be bound

12. He devours a pig or goat daily

13. My shattered constitution

14. The expression of my mortification

15. Neither of my colleagues particularly love me

16. Destroying the web of sophistry

17. Very gross rudeness

18. The most malignant and diabolical dispositions

19. A mean, lickspittle business

20. The gentlemen of the profession

21. A friend to free discussions

22. A vast and hitherto neglected, oppressed and deeply injured multitude

23. High and responsible situations

24. Circumstances have occurred

25. Over a glass of grog

26. The necessary directions

27. I like a clamour


Appendix A: Secretaries of State for War and the Colonies, 1827-1846

Appendix B: Cases heard by Judge Willis in the Supreme Court of New South Wales*


Select Bibliography


Subject Categories

BISAC Subject Codes/Headings:
SOCIAL SCIENCE / Criminology