The Legal Consequences of Limited Statehood: Palestine in Multilateral Frameworks, 1st Edition (Hardback) book cover

The Legal Consequences of Limited Statehood

Palestine in Multilateral Frameworks, 1st Edition

By Shadi Sakran

Routledge

192 pages | 2 B/W Illus.

Purchasing Options:$ = USD
Hardback: 9780367410278
pub: 2019-12-20
SAVE ~$31.00
Available for pre-order. Item will ship after 20th December 2019
$155.00
$124.00
x

FREE Standard Shipping!

Description

This book analyses Palestine’s acceptance as a State in multilateral frameworks and its legal consequences.

Using Palestine as a case study, this book argues that participation in a State-reserved regime is not determined by the traditional requisites of statehood. UNESCO membership unveils the acceptance of Palestine as a State for the limited purpose of the organization, without any immediate or implicit implications for the statehood of Palestine. Palestine’s accessions to various multilateral treaties demonstrate this argument as do its instruments of accession being accepted by the depositaries of both the United Nations Secretary-General and national Governments without requiring any clarification of the statehood question. This book also provides the first in-depth study of the legal relationship of rights and duties of Palestine with different groups of State Parties; the recent dispute settlement brought by Palestine against the United States and Israel; and theoretical and practical challenges for Palestine in the acceptance as a State in multilateral frameworks.

The book will be of interest to scholars and students of international law, legal theory, state law, and Middle East studies

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Acknowledgments

Acronyms

Table of International Instruments

Table of International Documents

Chapter 1

Limited Statehood in Multilateral Frameworks

1. General introduction

2. Why Palestine?

3. Research questions

4. Objectives and structure of the Book

5. The statehood question of Palestine?

Bibliography

 

Part 1 (Chapters 2-4)

Palestine in International Organizations

Chapter 2

Preliminary Examinations on Admissions to International Organizations

1. Admissions to international organizations

2. Rejection of implicit statehood

3. Rejection of collective recognition

4. Concluding observations

Bibliography

 

Chapter 3

Palestine in the UN: The Status of the Non-Member Observer State and its Consequences

1. Introduction

2. Historical background: Palestine’s status in the UN until Resolution 67/19

3.Does UN General Assembly Resolution 67/19 create a fully-fledged State of Palestine?

3.1.First argument: the term "State" may be taken to mean a fully-fledged State

3.2.Second argument: treating Palestine as an observer State may be binding upon all UN Member States

3.3.Third argument: those who voted for Resolution 67/19 must treat Palestine as a State

4. The consequences of the non-member observer State-status of Palestine

5. Conclusion

Bibliography

Chapter 4

Palestine in One of the Specialized Agencies of the UN: Palestine’s Admission to UNESCO and its Consequences

1. Introduction

2. Three hypotheses for the UNESCO admission clause

3. State in the UNESCO admission clause

3.1. The interpretation of the term "State" in the UNESCO admission clause

3.2. The practice of UNESCO in admitting Member States within the scope of Article II(2) of UNESCO’s Constitution

4. The admission of Palestine as a Member State by UNESCO

4.1. Palestine’s commitment and ability to carry out the functions of UNESCO

4.2. Voting record on Palestine’s admission to UNESCO

4.3. Concluding observations

5. The consequences of Palestine’s admission to UNESCO

5.1. Palestine’s relationship with opposing Member States after its admission

5.2. Palestine’s accession to UNESCO Treaties and their significant consequences

5.3. The entrance ticket of Palestine to Vienna Formula treaties

5.4. Political consequences of Palestine’s admission to UNESCO

6. Conclusion

Bibliography

Part 2 (Chapters 5-6)

Palestine in Multilateral Treaties

Chapter 5

Palestine’s Accession to Multilateral Treaties: The Circumvention of the Statehood Question by the Depositary

1. Introduction

2. Depositaries’ acceptance of the Palestinian instruments of accession

3. Multilateral treaties deposited with the UN Secretary-General

3.1. The "Vienna" clause:

3.2. All/Any States clause:

3.3. Concluding observations

4. Multilateral treaties deposited with national Governments

4.1. The Geneva Conventions and their Additional Protocols

4.2. The Hague Conventions and the Permanent Court of Arbitration

4.2.1. The "subsequent agreement" for accession to the 1907 Hague Convention for the Pacific Settlement

4.2.2. The role of the depositary: absence of institutional guidelines

4.2.3. The PCA Council has no Authority to suspend Palestine’s accession

4.2.4. Concluding observations

4.3. Multiple national Governments as depositaries: The NPT and BWC

5. Conclusion

Bibliography

Chapter 6

Consequences of Palestine’s Accession to Multilateral Treaties: Legal Relationships, Dispute Settlements and Functions of a Limited State

1. Introduction

2. Consequences for different groups of State Parties

2.1. Consequences for "silent States": silence may be seen as an acquiescence

2.2. Consequences of "purported" accessions for opposing States

3. Dispute settlements: Palestine against the United States and Israel

3.1. Palestine at the gates of the ICJ: Palestine against the United States

3.2. Palestine’s inter-State complaint against the State of Israel

4. Acting like a State

4.1. Substantive functions

4.2. Procedural functions

4.2.1. Submitting national reports

4.2.2. Participating in treaties’ conferences

5. Conclusion

Bibliography

Chapter 7

The Challenges for Palestine’s Participation as a State in Multilateral Frameworks: Imbalance, Occupation, and the Perceived Threat to the Peace Process

1. Introduction

2. Imbalanced participation in multilateral frameworks

2.1. Disadvantages compared to a formal State

2.2. Advantages compared to a formal State

3. Palestine as occupied territory

3.1. The requisite of effective control

3.2. Difficulties in implementing treaties’ provisions as a result of the occupation

4. Perceived threat to the peace process in the Middle East

5. Concluding observations

Bibliography

Chapter 8

Conclusion

1. Limited Statehood

2. The limited statehood of Palestine in multilateral frameworks

3. The legal consequences of limited statehood and the circumvention of the statehood question of Palestine

3.1. Confirmation of the general findings: observer State does not imply statehood

3.2. Limited Statehood of Palestine in international organizations

3.3. Limited Statehood of Palestine in multilateral treaties

4. Legal consequences of limited statehood of Palestine in multilateral frameworks

4.1. The contrast of what Palestine could do before and after its admission or accession

4.1.1. Palestine’s international legal capacity

4.1.2. Asserting sovereign rights over the Palestinian territory

4.1.3. Settling disputes in the international arena

4.2. Palestine’s legal relationships with different groups of State Parties

5. Final remarks: abandoning the traditional requisites of statehood?

Bibliography

Annex (1): List of Tables

Table (1): Countries Who Recognized Palestine as a State

Table (2): Voting Record of UN General Assembly Resolution 67/19

Table (3): Voting Record of the Executive Board on the Request of the Admission of Palestine to UNESCO

Table (4): Voting Record of the General Conference on the Request of the Admission of Palestine to UNESCO

Table (5): Countries Who Joined UNESCO Before their UN Admission

Table (6): Multilateral Treaties Deposited with the Director-General of UNESCO that were Acceded to by Palestine

Table (7): Multilateral Treaties Deposited with the UN Secretary-General that were Acceded to by Palestine

Table (8): Multilateral Treaties Deposited with National Governments that were Acceded to by Palestine

Table (9): Instruments of Accession, Ratification and Succession Deposited with the Three Depositories of the NPT

Annex (2): Maps of Palestine

Map (1): Plan of Partition

Map (2): City of Jerusalem

About the Author

Shadi Sakran is a post-doctoral researcher at Graduate School of International Cooperation Studies (GSICS), Kobe University, Japan.

Subject Categories

BISAC Subject Codes/Headings:
LAW000000
LAW / General