Truthfulness, Realism, Historicity A Study in Late Antique Spiritual Literature
Were holy men historical figures or figments of the theological imagination? Did the biographies devoted to them reflect facts or only the ideological commitments of their authors? For decades, scholars of late antiquity have wrestled with these questions when analysing such issues as the Christianization of Europe, the decline of paganism, and the 'rise of the holy man' and of the hagiographical genre. In this book Peter Turner suggests a new approach to these problems through an examination of a wide range of spiritual narrative texts from the third to the sixth centuries A.D.: pagan philosophical biographies, Greek and Latin Christian saints' lives, and autobiographical works by authors such as Julian and Augustine. Rather than scrutinizing these works for either historical facts or religious and intellectual attitudes, he argues that a deeper historicity can be found only in the interplay between these types of information. On the textual level, this analysis recognises the genuine commitment of spiritual authors to write truthfully and to record realistically a world felt to be replete with spiritual and symbolic meaning. On the historical level, it argues that holy men, expecting the same symbolism within their own lives, adopted lifestyles which ultimately provoked and confirmed this world view. Such praxis is detectable not only in the holy men who inspired biography but also in the period's scattered autobiographical writings. As much a historical as a textual phenomenon, this spiritually-minded scrutiny of the world created interpretations which were always open and contested. Therefore, this book also associates spiritual narrative texts with only one possible voice of religious experience in a constant dialogue between believers, opponents, and the sceptical undecided.
'Turner’s work is truly thought provoking... I believe that Turner’s achievement is a genuine one in that he makes his readers aware of the problems of interpreting late antique literature in a brief and well composed study.' Bryn Mawr Classical Review 'Truthfulness, Realism, Historicity is an ambitious and rewarding attempt to explain the thought world that stands behind much of late antiquity's literary production - more the careful unfolding of a mentalité in the French tradition than social history on the Brownian model. It is also a difficult work, requiring the reader's engagement not only with a broad range of pagan and Christian works in both Greek and Latin, but also a rich and eclectic array of modern literary theory and continental philosophy. Yet Turner's insights repay the intellectual effort.' Journal of Ecclesiastical History '... a richly textured, provocative, lucidly written, and dense book that is beautifully produced. It will prove most useful for graduate students and scholars of late antique hagiography, historians, and religious studies. ... this book offers a satisfying, sensible understanding as to how we might comprehend the miraculous and the holy through late antique eyes.' The Medieval Review '... an examination of a wide range of spiritual narrative texts from the third to the sixth centuries A.D. ... Rather than scrutinizing these works for either historical facts or religious and intellectual attitudes, he argues that a deeper historicity can be found only in the interplay between these types of information.' Studies in Spiritualities