1st Edition

The Management of Wicked Problems in Health and Social Care

    306 Pages
    by Routledge

    306 Pages
    by Routledge

    At a time of growing pressure on health and social care services, this book draws together contributions which highlight contemporary challenges for their management. Providing a range of contributions that draw on a Critical Management Studies perspective the book raises macro-level concerns with theory, demographics and economics on the one hand, as well as micro-level challenges of leadership, voice and engagement on the other. Rather than being an attempt to define the ‘wickedness’ of problems in this field, this book provides new insights designed to be of interest and value to researchers, students and managers.



    Contributions from international researchers explore four main topics:









      • identifying contemporary challenges in health and social care;






      • managing, leading and following;










      • listening to silent voices in delivering change; and






      • new methodologies for understanding care challenges.




    The concerns discussed in this volume are ‘wicked’ in so far as they are persistent, pernicious and beyond the curative abilities of any single organisation or profession. Such problems require collaboration but also new approaches to listening to those who suffer their effects. This book demonstrates such listening through its engagement with policy makers, leaders, followers, professions, patients, forgotten groups and silenced voices. Moreover, it considers how future research might be transformed so as to shine a more inclusive light on ‘wicked’ problems and their amelioration. This is a timely and engaging book that challenges you – the reader – to think again about how we should look at, engage with and support all those involved in health and social care.

    List of Contributors



    Acknowledgments



    Editors’ Introduction





    SECTION 1 Contemporary Wicked Challenges to Health and Social Care





    1 The Concept of Wicked Problems : Improving the Understanding of Managing Problem Wickedness in Health and Social Care



    HARRI RAISIO , ALISA PUUSTINEN AND PIRKKO VARTIAINEN





    2 The Politics of Care : Wicked Concerns Constituent in Care Reforms



    WILL THOMAS AND SUSAN HOLLINRAKE





    3 Personalization of Care : A Wicked Problem or a Wicked Solution?



    JANET CARTER ANAND , GAVIN DAVIDSON , BERNI KELLY AND GERALDINE MACDONALD





    SECTION 2 Managing, Leading and Following





    4 The Wicked Problem of Leadership in the NHS



    GAURISH CHAWLA AND MARK LEARMONTH





    5 Lofty Ideals and Lowly Troubles Among Nursing Home Managers



    MONICA ANDERSSON BÄCK AND CHARLOTTA LEVAY





    6 The Unnoticed Role of Employees in Ethical Leadership



    MERJA SINKKONEN AND SANNA LAULAINEN





    7 Destructive Leadership as a Wicked Problem in Health Care—Can We Blame the Leader Only?



    MINNA HOFFRÉN AND SANNA LAULAINEN





    8 Health Care Communication Technology and Its Promise of Patient Empowerment : Unpacking Patient Empowerment Through Patients’ Identity Constructions



    LAURA VISSER , INGE BLEIJENBERGH , YVONNE BENSCHOP AND ALLARD VAN RIEL





    SECTION 3 Silent Voice s: Making the Invisible Visible





    9 Blame Culture in the National Health Service (NHS), UK



    RUTH STRUDWICK





    10 A Darker Side to Interorganizational Relations



    KRISTINA BROWN





    11 Defi cit Discourses and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Disadvantage : A Wicked Problem in Australian Indigenous Policy?



    ELIZABETH PYLE , DEANNA GRANT-SMITH AND ROBYN MAYES





    12 Unpacking Dependency; Managing ‘Becoming’—Supporting the Experiences of Patients Living With Chronic Disease



    WILL THOMAS





    SECTION 4 Beyond Conventional Methodologies for Understanding Wicked Challenges





    13 Improving Young People’s Mental Health? Understanding Ambivalence to Seeking Support Among Young Adults With Asperger Syndrome



    EDMUND COLEMAN-FOUNTAIN AND BRYONY BERESFORD





    14 Action Research in the Health and Social Care Settings. A Tool for Solving Wicked Problems?



    MARTA STRUMI N SKA-KUTRA





    15 Four Different Ways to View Wicked Problems



    ANNELI HUJALA , SANNA LAULAINEN , ANDY BROOKES , MAARIT LAMMASSAARI AND TAMARA MULHERIN





    16 The Promise of Visual Approaches in Organizational and Management Research



    JARI MARTIKAINEN





    Index

    Biography

    Will Thomas is an Associate Professor in the University of Suffolk Business School, UK



    Anneli Hujala is a Senior Reseacher in the Department of Health and Social Management at the University of Eastern Finland



    Sanna Laulainen is a Senior Lecturer in the Department of Health and Social Management at the University of Eastern Finland



    Robert McMurray is Professor of Work and Organisation at The York Management School, UK