1st Edition

Arguing Global Governance Agency, Lifeworld and Shared Reasoning

Edited By Corneliu Bjola, Markus Kornprobst Copyright 2011
    320 Pages 7 B/W Illustrations
    by Routledge

    320 Pages 7 B/W Illustrations
    by Routledge

    This book deals with the questions of how global governance can and ought to effectively address serious global problems, such as financial instability, military conflicts, distributive injustice and increasing concerns of ecological disasters.

    Providing a unified theoretical framework, the contributors to this volume utilise argumentation research, broadening the concept by identifying the concerns about agency, lifeworld and shared reasoning that different strands of argumentation research have in common. Furthermore, they develop the concept of argumentative deontology in order to make sense of the processes through which argumentation comes to shape global governance.

    Empirically, the book demonstrates how ideas define actors’ interests, shape their interactions with each other, and ground intentions for collective action. Normatively, it provides an excellent theoretical platform for unveiling less visible manifestations of power in global politics and thereby improves our understandings of the ethical implications of global ordering.

    Addressing topical issues such as conflict and inter-civilizational dialogue, decision-making in international regimes and organizations, the World Social Forum, the Women’s Environment and Development Organization and Tobin Tax, this book will be of interest to students and scholars of argumentation theory, globalization and global governance

    1. Introduction: The Argumentative Deontology of Global Governance Corneliu Bjola and Markus Kornprobst  Part 1: Agency  2. Homo Politicus and Argument (Nearly) All the Way Down Neta Crawford  3. Governing Together Jennifer Mitzen  4. Framing Global Governance from Below Robert Benford  5. Substantive Issue-Linkage and the Politics of Migration Alexander Betts  Part 2: Lifeworld  6. Cultural Validation Antje Wiener  7. Intercivilizational Dialogue and Global Governance Homeira Moshirzadeh  8. Global Governance, Argumentation and Diversity Christopher Tindale  9. Scholarship Writ Large Markus Kornprobst  Part 3: Shared Reasons  10. Consensus, Compromise and "Inclusive Agreement" Christine Reh  11. The Power of the Public Sphere Corneliu Bjola  12. Argumentation in the Framework of the Deliberation Dialogue Douglas Walton, Katie Atkinson, Trevor Bench-Capon and Adam Wyner  13. Political Constructivism: Piki Ish-Shalom  14. Conclusion: A Deontological Agenda of Global Governance Corneliu Bjola and Markus Kornprobst


    Markus Kornprobst is Chair of International Relations at the Vienna School of International Studies, Diplomatische Akademie Wien.

    Corneliu Bjola is University Lecturer and a Fellow of St. Cross College at the University of Oxford.

    ‘An important theoretical contribution to the literature on global governance, with apposite contemporary applications. The editors and contributors synthesise Searle's institutional philosophy with argumentation theory into a novel deontology to explain how the structure of global governance arrangements are in part constituted by processes of argumentation between actors. This is a major constructivist contribution to our understanding of the social mechanisms by which global governance mechanisms are constructed.’ - Rodney Bruce Hall, University of Oxford, UK

    ‘Though there is widespread agreement that many of the most pressing problems confronting the world require global solutions, there is far less agreement about the authority and ability of the agencies of global governance to provide them. The contributors to this innovative collection suggest that an answer lies in the power of argument to provide collectively binding common norms and goals that can transcend the myopia, self-interest and cultural misunderstandings that stand in the way of concerted action. A fruitful combination of theoretical and empirical enquiry, whereby a general framework is explored through a number of case studies, this collection offers a powerful and exemplary exploration of one of the most urgent challenges confronting international politics today.’ - Richard Bellamy, University College London, UK