1st Edition

Assessing Outcomes in Child and Family Services Comparative Design and Policy Issues

Edited By Anthony N. Maluccio Copyright 2002
    192 Pages
    by Routledge

    180 Pages
    by Routledge

    In this collective portrait, editors and authors do not attempt to draw systematic, country-by-country comparisons. Given the magnitude of the issues, they believed that it would be inappropriate to paint with too broad a stroke. What they have accomplished, however, is to codify and identify what the participants repeatedly noted in regard to issues and difficulties inherent in conducting outcome evaluation. These include: varying definitions of outcome; complexities in measuring outcomes of particular interventions with different groups of consumers and documenting the effectiveness of the intervention; the tendency to focus on evaluation of process more than outcome; the challenge of involving practitioners in the evaluation task, in part because its value is unclear to them or perceived as distant or untrustworthy; the typical inadequacy of resources available for systematic evaluation; and the need to inject rigor into the design and execution of evaluation projects. The authors demonstrate strong conviction about sharing research expertise across national boundaries; learning through each other how to cope with organizational impediments to cross-national collaboration; and strengthening the interaction between practice and research. Their contributions suggest that there is wide interest in pursuing cross-national collaboration. In recent years, largely in response to demands by their funding sources for accountability, assessment of performance, and cost effectiveness, researchers in human services have been devoting increased attention to outcome evaluation. Limited attention, however, has been given to the findings of evaluation studies conducted in different countries. The present volume has been organized and edited to address the task of learning from outcome research across the world. Its goal, an extension of a major goal of the human services in any one country, is to improve life chances of vulnerable children and youth.

    Introduction: Outcome-Based Evaluation:
    Cross-National Perspectives
    Anthony N. Maluccio, Cinzia Canali, and Tiziano Vecchiato
    1 Current Initiatives in the Development of Outcome-Based
    Evaluation of Children's Services
    Harriet Ward
    2 The Black Box: Accounting for Program Inputs When
    Assessing Outcomes
    Edith Fein
    3 The Evaluation of "Community Building": Measuring the
    Social Effects of Community-Based Practice
    Robert J. Chaskin
    4 Outcome-Based Evaluation of National Health and
    Social Programs
    Tiziano Vecchiato
    5 Nonexperimental Methods of Evaluating Social Programs:
    Applications for Child and Family Services
    Robert Goerge
    6 An Intervention to Reduce Smoking Habits through
    Counseling from the General Practitioner
    Giovanni Pilati, Elizabeth Tamang, and Luca Gino Sbrogio
    7 Improving Mental Health Care for Children and Adolescents:
    Strategies and Lessons
    John Landsverk and Inger Davis
    8 Evaluating Social and Health Services with Children,
    Adults, and Elderly Persons
    Alessandro Pompei
    9 Outcomes Are Dependent on Inputs: Does Risk Assessment
    Inform Service Delivery?
    Marianne Berry and Scottye J. Cash
    10 A Learning-Organization Approach to Evaluation
    Lois Wright and Kathy Paget
    11 Outcome Studies in the Context of Organizational Inertia
    and Political Ideology
    Frank Ainsworth
    12 Family Service Centers: Lessons From National and
    Local Evaluations
    Anita Lightburn
    Author Index
    Subject Index


    Anthony N. Maluccio