1st Edition

Assisted Reproduction, Discrimination, and the Law

By Michelle Weldon-Johns Copyright 2020
146 Pages
by Routledge

146 Pages
by Routledge

146 Pages
by Routledge

The numbers of women undergoing Assisted Reproduction Technology (ART) treatments have risen steadily, yet they remain largely outside the scope of equality and employment law protection while undergoing treatment. Assisted Reproduction, Discrimination, and the Law examines this gap in UK law, with reference to EU law as appropriate, and argues that new conceptions of equality are necessary.... Read more

Chapter 1: Introduction

Introduction

Assisted reproduction Technologies (ART) treatments

Assisted reproduction, discrimination and the law

Chapter overviews

Chapter 2: Current conceptions of equality and the limitations for those involved in assisted reproduction

Introduction

Pre-conception protection: the limitations of EU and UK law

Childcare rights: Commissioning mothers in surrogacy

The jurisprudence on commissioning mothers

The Children and Families Act 2014

A multidimensional, multiple or intersectional approach towards equality law?

Multidimensional discrimination and the legal framework

Setting the theoretical frame: ART treatments and intersectionality

Conclusion

Chapter 3: Conceiving a more social model of disability: infertility as disability

Introduction

Intersectionality, Infertility and models of disability

Infertility and the medical model of disability

Infertility and the limitations of the EU interpretation of the social model of disability

Reinterpreting disability: adopting an intersectionality approach

Infertility as disability: the Americans with Disabilities Act 1990

Challenging the boundaries of disability

Infertility as disability: reproduction confirmed as ‘a major life activity’

Reinterpreting disability: Lessons for the UK

An alternative interpretation of disability

Infertility and additional CRPD obligations

Conclusion

Chapter 4: Conceiving a new interpretation of pregnancy and sex discrimination: redefining the boundaries

Introduction

Intersectionality and the boundaries of gender discrimination

Pregnancy discrimination: from gender equality to specific rights

The limitations of pregnancy discrimination

Sex discrimination revisited

Redefining the boundaries: adopting an intersectionality approach

The Pregnancy Discrimination Act 1978

From ‘a related medical condition’ to a focus on childbearing capacity

Redefining pregnancy-related discrimination in the UK

Reinterpreting pregnancy

Associative pregnancy discrimination

Conclusion

Chapter 5: A right to time off work to undergo ART treatments

Introduction

Combining work and ART treatment: without a legal framework

Statutory sick pay

The right to request flexible working

Rights to time off during the ante-natal period

A right to medical leave

The Family and Medical Leave Act 1993

A right to time off work to undergo ART treatments: Possibilities for the UK

Conclusion

Chapter 6: Conclusions

Introduction

Recognising alternative routes to parenthood

Recognising the social value of procreation

Overcoming barriers

Adopting an intersectional analysis

Recommendations

Conclusion

Index

Biography

Dr Michelle Weldon-Johns is a lecturer in Employment Law at Abertay University in Dundee. Her specific research interest is the boundaries between work and family life from UK and EU employment and equality law perspectives. Her research focuses on gender equality and the work-family conflict, particularly from the perspectives of working fathers and atypical working families. She has also written on the potential implications of Brexit for Scotland in the employment and work-family context.