1st Edition

Collective Action, Philosophy and Law

Edited By Teresa Marques, Chiara Valentini Copyright 2022
    312 Pages 2 B/W Illustrations
    by Routledge

    312 Pages 2 B/W Illustrations
    by Routledge

    Collective Action, Philosophy and Law brings together two important strands of philosophical analysis. It combines general philosophical inquiry into collective agency with analyses of specific questions about plural entities and activities in the legal domain. These are issues of growing interest in areas of philosophy like action theory and social ontology, as well as in philosophy of law.

    The book contains 13 original chapters written by an international team of leading philosophers and legal theorists and is divided into 4 parts:

    • The nature of law and of legislative intention
    • Practical reasoning and duties
    • Causality, blameworthiness and responsibility
    • Citizens, states and institutions.

    These sections cut across, and build on, different accounts to advance the debate on classical and new issues in collective agency. Each part also features legal-philosophical analyses that draw on general accounts of collective agency to cast new light on the law, descriptive as well as normatively.

    Collective Action, Philosophy and Law is the first major interdisciplinary and multi-authored work bridging legal and philosophical approaches to collective agency. As such, it is essential reading for students and researchers of philosophy of law, ethics, political philosophy, jurisprudence and legal theory.

    Introduction: Collective Action and the Law Teresa Marques and Chiara Valentini

    Part 1: The Nature of Law and Legislative Intention

    1. Collectivity and Law Kevin Toh

    2. Legislative Intent, Collective Intentionality and Fictionalism Damiano Canale

    3. Legal Disagreement as Disagreement About the Collectively Intended Meaning Brian Flanagan

    4. The Two Lives of Law’s Moral Aim Dimitrios Kyritsis

    Part 2: Practical Reasoning and Duties

    5. Judicial Community and Team Reasoning Natalie Gold

    6. "I Thought we Were on the Same Team!": Collective duties and individual moral orientation Caroline Arruda

    7. Directed Duties, Practical Intimacy, and Legal Wronging  Abe Roth

    Part 3: Causality, Blameworthiness and Responsibility

    8. Responsibility Unincorporated: Group Agents and Corporate Persons Sara Rachel Chant

    9. Deviant Causation and the Law Sara Bernstein

    10. Forceability, Causation, and Guilt  Nicholas Almendares

    Part 4: Citizens, States, and Institutions

    11. Expressive Theories of Punishment Bill Wringe

    12. There’s no I in Team: Judicial Review and Community Moral Agents Maggie O’Brien

    13. One Among Many: Self-governance and Alienation in Mass Action Carla Bagnoli.



    Teresa Marques is Profesora Agregada (Associate Professor) in the Philosophy Department at the University of Barcelona, Spain. She is also a member of the LOGOS Group and of the Barcelona Institute of Analytic Philosophy. With Åsa Wikforss she is editor of Shifting Concepts: The Philosophy and Psychology of Conceptual Variability (2020). She has published in journals like Philosophical Studies, The Australasian Journal of Philosophy, Synthese, Erkenntnis, Inquiry, Thought, Ratio, Philosophia and Metaphilosophy.

    Chiara Valentini is Senior Researcher in Philosophy of Law at the University of Bologna Law Department, Italy. With Bongiovanni, Postema, Rotolo, Sartor and Walton, she is editor of the Handbook of Legal Reasoning and Argumentation (2018). Her work has been published in journals like Law and Philosophy, The American Journal of Jurisprudence, Ratio Juris and Jurisprudence.