Contact, Conquest and Colonization How Practices of Comparing Shaped Empires and Colonialism Around the World
Contact, Conquest and Colonization brings together international historians and literary studies scholars in order to explore the force of practices of comparing in shaping empires and colonial relations at different points in time and around the globe.
Whenever there was cultural contact in the context of European colonization and empire-building, historical records teem with comparisons among those cultures. This edited volume focuses on what historical agents actually do when they compare, rather than on comparison as an analytic method. Its contributors are thus interested in the ‘doing of comparison’, and explore the force of these practices of comparing in shaping empires and (post-)colonial relations between the sixteenth and twentieth centuries.
This book will appeal to students and scholars of global history, as well as those interested in cultural history and the history of colonialism.
Introduction: On ‘Doing Comparison’ – Practices of Comparing Eleonora Rohland and Kirsten Kramer
Part I: Women, Marriage Practices, and Morals
1. Bridging the Gap: Jesuit Missionaries’ Perspectives on Marriage in the Philippines in the Period of Contact Marya Svetlana T. Camacho
2. Constructing the Literati: The Jesuits’ Attempt to Understand China’s Confucian Elite by Dint of Comparison Nadine Amsler
3. ‘Our’ Women, ‘Their’ Women: Domestic Space and the Question of Modernisation in Nineteenth Century Colonial India Subhasri Ghosh
Part II: Politics, Polemics, and Propaganda
4. Entre Nos: Comparison and Authority in the Epistolary of Antonio Valeriano Ezekiel Stear
5. Global Benchmarks of Princely Rule in the Early Eighteenth Century? Transcultural Comparison in the Political Series of the German Publisher Renger (1704-1718) Volker Bauer
6. Spain and its North-African ‘Other.’ Ambivalent Practices of Comparing in the Context of Modern Spanish Colonialism around 1860 Sara Mehlmer
7. Propaganda, Cultural Diplomacy and the Politics of Comparison in the Early Cold War, 1945 to the 1960s Benno Nietzel
Part III: Literature, Science, and Literary Discourse
8. Same Sky, Different Soil: Geographical Difference in Eighteenth-Century Astronomy and its Impact on Literature Alexander Honold
9. Between Nature and Culture: Comparing, Natural History, and Anthropology in Modern French Travel Narratives Around 1800 (François-René de Chateaubriand) Kirsten Kramer
10. Comparison as Context in Sir William Jones’s Translations of Eastern Literature Catharina G.M. Janssen
Part IV: Race, Civilization, and Religion
11. Colonizing Complexions: How Laws of Bondage Shaped Race in America’s Colonial Borderlands Christian Pinnen
12. Tocqueville’s Compass: On History, Race and Comparison in A Fortnight in the Wilds Julian T. D. Gärtner
13. Climates, Colonialism, and the Politics of Comparison: The Construction of U.S.-American Tropicality in Colonial Medicine and Public Health, 1898-1912 Julia Engelschalt
14. Between ‘Cannibals’ and ‘Natural Freemasons:’ The (Anti)Colonial History of Comparing Freemasonry to African Secret Societies Stephanie Zehnle
Concluding Observations: Modes of Comparing and Communities of Practice Angelika Epple and Antje Flüchter