1st Edition

Contestatory Cosmopolitanism

Edited By Tom Bailey Copyright 2017
    162 Pages
    by Routledge

    162 Pages
    by Routledge

    Contemporary global politics poses urgent challenges – from humanitarian, migratory and environmental problems to economic, religious and military conflicts – that strain not only existing political systems and resources, but also the frameworks and concepts of political thinking. The standard cosmopolitan response is to invoke a sense of global community, governed by such principles as human rights or humanitarianism, free or fair trade, global equality, multiculturalism, or extra-national democracy. Yet, the contours, grounds and implications of such a global community remain notoriously controversial, and it risks abstracting precisely from the particular and conflictual character of the challenges which global politics poses.

    The contributions to this collection undertake to develop a more fruitful cosmopolitan response to global political challenges, one that roots cosmopolitanism in the particularity and conflict of global politics itself. They argue that this ‘contestatory’ cosmopolitanism must be dialectical, agonistic and democratic: that is, its concepts and principles must be developed immanently and critically out of prevailing normative resources; they must reflect and acknowledge their antagonistic roots; and they must be the result of participatory and self-determining publics. In elaborating this alternative, the contributions also return to neglected cosmopolitan theorists like Hegel, Adorno, Arendt, Camus, Derrida, and Mouffe, and reconsider mainstream figures such as Kant and Habermas.

    This collection was originally published as a special edition of Critical Horizons.

    Introduction Tom Bailey

    1. Cosmopolitanism and the Modern Revolutionary Tradition: Reflections on Arendt’s Politics Robert Fine

    2. National Sovereigntism and Global Constitutionalism: An Adornian Cosmopolitan Critique Lars Rensmann

    3. A Brief Sketch of the Possibility of a Hegelian Cosmopolitanism David Edward Rose

    4. Overcoming Statism from Within: The International Criminal Court and the Westphalian System Kevin W. Gray and Kafumu Kalyalya

    5. Cosmopolitanism From Below: Universalism as Contestation James D. Ingram

    6. Farewell to Teleology: Reflections on Camus and a Rebellious Cosmopolitanism without Hope Patrick Hayden

    7. Towards an Agonistic Cosmopolitanism: Exploring the Cosmopolitan Potential of Chantal Mouffe’s Agonism Tamara Caraus

    8. Citizens and Strangers: Cosmopolitanism as an Empty Universal John Rundell

    9. From Self-Legislation to Self-Determination: Democracy and the New Circumstances of Global Politics James Bohman

    10. Law and (Global) Order: Towards a Theory of Cosmopolitan Policing William Smith


    Tom Bailey is Associate Professor of Philosophy at John Cabot University in Rome, Italy. He works on modern and contemporary ethics and political philosophy. He has published essays on Kant and Nietzsche, and edited Nietzsche and Kantian Ethics (with J Constâncio, London: Bloomsbury, 2017),  Rawls and Religion (with V. Gentile, New York: Columbia University Press, 2015) and Deprovincializing Habermas: Global Perspectives (London: Routledge, 2013).