1st Edition

Cursed Blessings Sex and Religious Radical Dissent in Early Modern Europe

Edited By Umberto Grassi Copyright 2024
    178 Pages 8 B/W Illustrations
    by Routledge

    Cursed Blessings explores the relationship between sexual nonconformity and religious radical dissent in the early modern Western European world. While many studies have been devoted to the process of the "hereticalization" of nonnormative sexual practices and its use in anti-heretical propaganda, this book is entirely devoted to understanding the meaning of unconventional sexual behaviors from the perspective of the dissenters.

    Divided into three parts, the first focuses on the Italian peninsula and explores alternative views on sexuality inspired by Renaissance currents of anti-clericalism, ancient Christian heresies, traditions of apocrypha of the New Testament, and Rabbinic literature. It also examines how embodied and gendered experiences influenced the dissenting views of religious women. The second part explores how reflections on Original Sin led to the questioning of Christian assumptions regarding sex and gender, highlighting the relationship between the criticism of sexual morality and disputes on free will, spirituality, and redemption. The third part examines how most of these threads were entwined into a more coherent philosophical framework in the writings of seventeenth- and eighteenth-century erudite libertines.

    This book is designed for academic readers, including graduate and undergraduate students. Given its intersectional approach, it will be of interest to researchers, teachers, and students in a wide array of fields, including religious, gender, and sexuality studies, as well as literature. This book also tackles issues that are relevant to present-day debates, such as the problematic relations between sexuality and religion and the ongoing polemics surrounding the complicated interactions between religion and politics.

    Umberto Grassi

    Introduction: Sexual Nonconformity and Religious Dissent in Early Modern Europe

     

    Part 1: Sex and the body as a form of resistance to Catholic Orthodoxy

     

    Lucia Felici

    A Sixteenth-Century Libertine Priest: Francesco Calcagno 

     

    Vittorio Frajese

    The Disciple whom Jesus Loved

     

    Isabel Harvey

    The Venetian Inquisition and the bodies of Nuns. The Trial Against Suor Cecilia Sacrati, 1701-1706

     

    Part 2: Heretical reinterpretations of original sin in Germany and the Netherlands

     

    Dario Gurashi

    Decrypting Adam and Eve: Agrippa on Sexuality and Redemption

     

    Gary K. Waite

    Adam, Eve, and the Serpent in David Joris’ Radical Spiritualism    

     

    Karen E. Hollewand

    The Banished Scholar: Beverland, Sex, and Liberty

    in the Seventeenth-Century Low Countries               

     

    Part 3: Between elite discourses and popular innuendos: European erudite libertinism

     

    Jean-Pierre Cavaillé

    The Philosophical Meaning of Sexual Transgressions: ‘Libertins Érudit’ and Sodomy

     

    Peter Cryle

    The Moral Radicalism of Libertine Dalliance in Eighteenth-Century France

     

    Biography

    Umberto Grassi is an independent scholar. He specializes in early modern history and has published on the history of sexuality, religious radical dissent, cultural history, and the history of emotions. He has held research positions at the Scuola Normale Superiore of Pisa and the University of Sydney as a research fellow of the ARC Centre of Excellence for the History of Emotions. From 2018 to 2021, he was a Marie Skłodowska-Curie fellow at the University of Verona and the University of Maryland. His previous publications include Bathhouses and Riverbanks: Sodomy in a Renaissance Republic (2021).