1st Edition

Ethics and Experiments Problems and Solutions for Social Scientists and Policy Professionals

Edited By Scott Desposato Copyright 2016
    336 Pages 7 B/W Illustrations
    by Routledge

    336 Pages 7 B/W Illustrations
    by Routledge

    For most of political science's history, discussions about professional ethics had nothing to do with human subjects. Professional ethics involved integrity in the classroom, fair tenure and promotion rule, and the careful avoidance of plagiarism. As most research was observational, there was little need for attention to how scholarly activities might directly affect the subjects of our work. Times have changed. The dramatic growth in the use of experiments in social science, especially overseas, is generating unexpected ethical controversies. The purpose of this volume is to identify, debate, and propose practical solutions to the most critical of these new ethical issues.

    A leading team of internationally distinguished political science scholars presents the first examination of the practical and ethical challenges of research with human subjects in social science and policy studies.

    Part 1 examines contextual challenges provided by experiments conducted overseas - questions of culture, religion, security, and poverty.

    Part 2 examines questions of legal constraints on research, focusing on questions of foreign review of international experiments.

    Part 3 tackles the critical issues in field experiments, including deception and consent, impact on elections and careers, the boundaries of the public officials' exemption, and the use of partner organizations to avoid Institutional Review Body (IRB) review.

    Part 4 considers strategies for the future, including training and education, IRB reform, institutional changes, and norm development.

    1. Introduction Scott Desposato  Part 2:Contextual Challenges for Experimentalists  2. The Ethics of Exclusion When Experimenting in Impoverished Settings Kim Yi Dionne, Augustine Harawa, and Hastings Honde  3. Ethics for Experimental Manipulation of Religion Richard A. Nielsen  4. Religion, Experiments, and Ethical Concerns Rebecca Morton and Jonathan Rogers  5. Prison States and Games of Chicken Jesse Driscoll  Part 3: Local Ethical Review when Conducting Experiments Internationally  6. The Value and Challenges of Using Local Ethical Review in Comparative Politics Experiments Jennifer L. Merolla and Raul Madrid Jr.  7. Ethical Challenges in Comparative Politics Experiments in China  Xiaobo Lü  8. Local Review: Confronting the Brazilian Black Box Saul Cunow and Scott Desposato  9. Ethical Perspectives in Countries without an Institutional Review Board: The Case of Mexico Rosario Aguilar  Part 3: The Ethical Challenges of Field Experiments  10. Obligated to Deceive? Aliases, Confederates, and the Common Rule in International Field Experiments Michael Findley and Daniel Nielson  11. Considering the Political Consequences of Comparative Politics Experiments Joshua R. Gubler and Joel S. Selway  12. Information and Power: Ethical Considerations of Political Information Experiments Brigitte Zimmerman  13. Conducting Research with NGOs: Relevant Counterfactuals from the Perspective of Subjects David W. Nickerson and Susan D. Hyde  14. Manipulating Elites Edmund J. Malesky  15. Field Experiments on Elected and Public Officials: Ethical Obligations and Requirements Christian R. Grose  Part 4: Strategies for Moving Forward  16. Human Subjects Protection and Large-N Research: When Exempt is Non-Exempt and Research is Non-Research Mitchell A. Seligson  17. Ethics and Research in Political Science: The Responsibilities of the Researcher and the Profession Elizabeth J. Zechmeister  18. Journal Editors as Ethics Sheriffs Rick K. Wilson, William Mishler, and John Ishiyama  19. Conclusion and Recommendations Scott Desposato


    Scott Desposato has held positions at the University of Zurich, the University of Arizona, as well as the Harvard Academy, and is currently Associate Professor of Political Science at University of California, San Diego, USA. His research interests include American and comparative elections, institutions, voting behavior, and methodology.

    'A must-read for researchers and practitioners who use experiments.' - Emily Beaulieu, University of Kentucky, USA

    'The notion that social science research is minimal risk research is no longer valid in many regions of the world today. Meeting the needs of the international research community facing ethical challenges emanating from global political, religious, cultural and economic diversity, this volume provides empirically driven guidance and policy recommendations for the ethical conduct of social science research on a global scale. The book’s many scholarly contributions by social and political scientists an important resource for Institutional Review Boards, policy makers, and social scientists responsible for the ethical conduct of international field research in a dynamic geopolitical landscape.' - Michael P. Caligiuri, University of California, San Diego, USA

    'This anthology makes significant contributions to the ethics of experimental political science. The authors identify troubling issues, propose best practices, and, most importantly, encourage future dialogue on ethical issues that will arise in experimental political science. Anyone conducting experiments in political science must read this book.' - Trisha Phillips, West Virginia University, USA