1st Edition

Evolving Strategies for Writing Feedback on Creative Manuscripts A Multi-Genre Pedagogy Guide

Edited By Leah McCormack Copyright 2026
262 Pages 20 B/W Illustrations
by Routledge

262 Pages 20 B/W Illustrations
by Routledge

Evolving Strategies for Writing Feedback on Creative Manuscripts: A Multi-Genre Pedagogy Guide is a practical and essential resource for instructors of undergraduate and graduate creative writing courses. Designed for the novice and established instructor alike, it sheds light on a critical but often mysterious aspect of the creative writing classroom: writing comments on student work.... Read more

Introduction

LEAH MCCORMACK

UNITED STATES

I: Poetry

1 The Forest to Come: Notes on a Pedagogy of Process

MICHAEL LEONG

UNITED STATES

2 “Notes From Sue”: Commenting on Poetry

SUE SINCLAIR

CANADA

3 Seeing the Feedback for the Words: Reflecting on Feedback for Neurodivergent Students

VANA MANASIADIS

NEW ZEALAND

4 Dowsing the Depths, Not Digging the Well

RUTH WILLIAMS

UNITED STATES

5 Practicalities, Physicalities: Alternative Ways of Giving Feedback (on Visual Poetry)

KIMBERLY CAMPANELLO

ENGLAND

II: Fiction

6 Rationale, a Conversation between Tarini Fernando and Heather Jessup

TARINI FERNANDO AND HEATHER JESSUP

CANADA

7 The Writing Workshop: Teaching Students to Rest Easy with Uncertainty

KAREN STEVENS

ENGLAND

8 Pattern Recognition and the Art of Literary Craft

RONE SHAVERS

UNITED STATES

9 Historical Fiction and the Modern Workshop

NAOMI WOOD

ENGLAND

10 There’s Always a Reason Why

CHIKA UNIGWE

UNITED STATES

III

Nonfiction 157

11 Asking Questions, Valuing Voices

CLAIRE HYNES

ENGLAND

12 Deepening and Complicating: The Creative Nonfiction Workshop 171

MICHAEL D. BURKE

UNITED STATES

13 Workshops Without Real-Time: Fostering Craft-Critical Feedback in Online, Asynchronous Creative Writing Courses

TARA PROPPER

UNITED STATES

14 A Comment on Comments

ROBERT ANTHONY SIEGEL

SINGAPORE / UNITED STATES

15 “Write What You Know”: International Students, Acculturation Stress, and Teaching Creative Nonfiction

KERRIE M. DAVIES

AUSTRALIA

IV: Appendices

Appendix A: A Scaffolded, Dramaturgical Approach

MARITA DACHSEL

CANADA

Appendix B: Writing Identity and Difference

JEANINE LEANE

AUSTRALIA

Biography

Leah McCormack is Associate Professor of English at the University of South Dakota, USA.