1st Edition

Gender Justice and Proportionality in India
Comparative Perspectives

ISBN 9780367886219
Published December 12, 2019 by Routledge
230 Pages

USD $49.95

Prices & shipping based on shipping country


Book Description

For a judiciary in a democracy, dispensing justice is not only about doing justice, but also about showing that justice is being done; it is about giving reasons and creating a "culture of justification". The question becomes how to nurture such a culture. A number of liberal democratic jurisdictions have answered this question in part with the adoption of the multi-step method of evaluating the constitutionality of legislative infringements on fundamental rights widely known as Proportionality Analysis. Under Proportionality Analysis courts must engage in a structured process of reasoning.

This book deals with Gender Justice and Proportionality Analysis in India. The author argues that the Supreme Court of India should consider adopting Proportionality Analysis for the adjudication of the fundamental right to sex equality in Indian courts. The book includes an analysis of Canadian and South African Proportionality Analysis and makes some suggestions on how an Indian Proportionality Analysis could be generated using this comparative investigation. Additionally, the book proposes ways of applying the effects of socio-political context on doctrine, as well as doctrine’s interpretive impact on adjudicated outcomes for gender, thus making a contribution to feminist jurisprudence. Finally, the author analyses Indian gender equality jurisprudence, demonstrating the inadequacies of the current doctrinal framework for achieving the goal of substantive gender equality and suggesting ways in which an Indian Proportionality Analysis might be fashioned to address these inadequacies.

A novel examination of the gender situation in India in comparative perspective, this book will be of interest to academics in the field of Gender Studies, Asian and Comparative Law and South Asian studies.

Table of Contents

1. Acknowledgements
2. List of abbreviations
3. Introduction to Proportionality and Gender Equality
4. Constitutional Courts in Context:  India, Canada and South Africa
5. The Adjudication of Gender Equality in Independent India: Judicial Discourse from Deference to Discord
6. The Theoretical Foundations of Proportionality Analysis
7. Proportionality Analysis in Canadian Gender Equality Jurisprudence
8. Proportionality Analysis in South African Gender Equality Jurisprudence
9. Defining an Indian Proportionality Analysis for Gender Equality and Beyond
10. Index

View More



Juliette Gregory Duara is a Senior Fellow at the Kenan Institute for Ethics, Duke University, USA.