1st Edition

Interpreting Music, Engaging Culture An Introduction to Music Criticism

By Katherine Walker Copyright 2025
202 Pages 27 B/W Illustrations
by Routledge

202 Pages 27 B/W Illustrations
by Routledge

202 Pages 27 B/W Illustrations
by Routledge

Interpreting Music, Engaging Culture: An Introduction to Music Criticism offers a clear, hands-on guide for emerging music critics that brings together aesthetics, critical theory, and practical music criticism in an accessible format. Over the course of the book, readers develop a vocabulary and framework for criticizing music of all kinds and for various media while learning how to connect... Read more

Contents

 

Introduction

A Critical Engagement with Music

 

Critical Discourse

From Critical to Criticism

What’s Not Criticism?

Why do Criticism?

Chapter Summary

Guide Questions

 

PART ONE: AESTHETIC FOUNDATIONS

 

Chapter One

What is Art? The Musical Work Problem

 

The Musical Work Concept

Getting to Know the Musical Work

Historically Informed Performance (HIP) Movement

Getting to Know Technical Aspects of the Performance

Getting to Know Interpretive Aspects of the Performance

The Musical Work and Value

The Case of Popular Music

Chapter Summary

Guide Questions

 

Chapter Two

Authenticity

 

Defining Authenticity

Folk Authenticity

Authenticity in Hip Hop

Chapter Summary

Guide Questions

 

Chapter Three

Beyond Authenticity

 

Postmodernism

Postmodern Music and Its Criticism

Postmodernism in a Post-Truth Era

Chapter Summary

Guide Questions

 

PART TWO: CRITICIZING MUSIC

 

Chapter Four

Describing Music

 

Elements of Music

Genre

Style Period

Contexts for Consumption

Chapter Summary

Guide Questions

 

Chapter Five

Interpreting Music

 

Musical Interpretation

Interpretive Strategies

Chapter Summary

Guide Questions

 

Chapter Six

Evaluating Music

 

Some Negative Criticism of Negative Criticism

Evaluation and the Work’s Purpose

The Value of the Purpose

The Critic as Educator

Chapter Summary

Guide Questions

 

PART THREE: CRITICAL LENSES

 

Chapter Seven

Feminist Music Criticism

 

Feminism and Feminisms

Why do we Need Feminism?

History of Feminisms

Feminism and Music

Feminist Criticism

Chapter Summary

Guide Questions

 

Chapter Eight

Queer Music Criticism

 

Gender Queer

Queering the Patriarchy

Music and Queer Expression

Camp isn’t Always Queer

Queer isn’t Always Camp

Queer Criticism as History and Allyship

Chapter Summary

Guide Questions

 

Chapter Nine

Postcolonialism and Critical Race Theory

 

Orientalism

Postcolonialism

Postcolonialism and Critical Race Theory

Chapter Summary

Guide Questions

 

Chapter Ten

Music and Consumer Culture

 

The Case of Popular Music\

Hybrid Advertising in Popular Music

Music and Marketing in the Age of Social Media

Chapter Summary

Guide Questions

 

PART FOUR: CRITICAL CONTEXTS

 

Chapter Eleven

Album and Track-by-Track Reviews

 

Album Review in the Age of Streaming

Track By Track Review

Writing for a Specific Publication

Chapter Summary

Guide Questions

 

Chapter Twelve

Program Notes and the Live Concert Review

 

Program Notes as Guide

Live Review

Chapter Summary

Guide Questions

Biography

Katherine Walker is Associate Professor of Music at Hobart & William Smith Colleges.