1st Edition

Irreverence and Psychoanalysis

Edited By Jean Petrucelli, Sarah Schoen Copyright 2027
258 Pages
by Routledge

258 Pages
by Routledge

This book explores the role of psychoanalysis as an irreverent discipline—questioning received wisdoms, challenging internal and external constraints, and unearthing links between the outlandish and the transformative. Psychoanalysis is a field exquisitely suited to embracing complication and contradiction. Irreverence can be complex, as it risks disrespect for what others value or cherish. Yet... Read more

Introduction
Jean Petrucelli and Sarah Schoen

Section I: Getting into Good Trouble: Race, Sex, and Enthusiasms

01. Irreverence and Humor in Theory and Practice: A Resource to Help with Mystifications and Misconceptions
Stephen Seligman

02. Notes from the Erotic Field: Potholes, Confessions, Discoveries
Sarah Schoen

03. Irreverence: A Necessary Component of Psychoanalytic Identity and Practice in our Authoritarian and Racist World
Dorothy Holmes


04. Irreverence as Love from Close-in Rather Than Far-away: “Good Trouble” from John Lewis to Interpersonal and Relational Psychoanalysis
Anton Hart

Section II: Between Two Points: Stretching Beyond Outside in and Inside Out as our Loyalties are Challenged

05. Remaking Psyches in a World Being Remade
Susie Orbach

06. Ethical Irreverence, or an Analyst Outside of History
Orna Guralnik

07. ALL BORN SCREAMING: Where have all our Appetites and Desires Gone?
Jean Petrucelli


Section III: Humans, Minds, and Brains: A Trialogue at the edge of AI Possibility

08. Reverence and Irreverence
Amy Levy

09. Does Your Bot Give a Damn? A brief Neuropsychoanalytic Perspective on LLM’s
Fred Gioia

10. You’re Already an AI Revolutionary! But On Whose Side?
Todd Essig

11. Amy Levy’s Response
Amy Levy

12. Fred Gioia’s Response
Fred Gioia

13. Todd Essig’s Response
Todd Essig


Section IV: Approach with Irreverence: Psychoanalysis, Gender & Sexuality


14. A 1970’s Feminist Psychoanalyst’s Perspective on Gender, Sex, Sexualities
Ann D’Ercole

15. May You Live in Interesting Times: Some Irreverent Reflections on Psychoanalytic Grandiosity
Jack Drescher

16. Some Thoughts on Gender
Willa N. France

17. When Irreverent Defiance is Needed: A Call to Action
Jack Pula

Section V: Don't talk to THOSE People! Does Irreverence calm the waters or fuel the flames of toxic polarization?

18. THEM’S FIGHTIN’ WORDS: RHETORIC AND POLARIZATION
Sue Kolod

19. Bullet in the Brain: Reverence, Irreverence, and the Pursuit of Dialogue
Tom Hennes

20. The Gaza Ordeal; Our Sadistic Moment
Susannah Heschel

Section VI: Irreverence and Orthodoxy In Psychoanalysis

21. ON IRREVERENCE
Adam Phillips

22. Slow Therapy: Psychoanalysis as Counterculture
Don Greif

23. Genocide and the Screen of Irreverence
Avgi Saketopoulou

24. Defiant Voices: Language, Irreverence, and Impeccable Speech
Velleda C. Ceccoli

Biography

Jean Petrucelli, Ph.D., CEDS-C is Training & Supervising Analyst, Faculty, Director, and Co-Founder of the Eating Disorders, Compulsions and Addictions Service. She is Director of the one-year educational training program (EDCAS) and Conference Advisory Board Committee Chair at the William Alanson White Institute. She is an Adjunct Clinical Professor and Clinical Consultant, NYU Postdoctoral in Psychotherapy and Psychoanalysis, and Associate Editor for Contemporary Psychoanalysis.

Sarah Schoen, PhD is Training & Supervising Analyst and Faculty at the William Alanson White Institute. She is an Adjunct Clinical Professor and Clinical Consultant for NYU’s Postdoctoral Program in Psychotherapy and Psychoanalysis and Invited Faculty at the Columbia University Center for Psychoanalytic Training and Research. She is also on the Editorial Board for Contemporary Psychoanalysis and Executive Editor of Psychoanalytic Dialogues.

'Irreverence and Psychoanalysis is a volume with the bravery to say what psychoanalysis has always known but often forgotten: truth flourishes in unsettlement, creativity is bound up with transgression, and our deepest work relies on the freedom to question what we hold sacred. This book is remarkably vital, bold but not reckless, thoughtful but not timid, and unafraid to venture into the fraught spaces where the political, the personal, and the clinical intersect. Throughout its pages, the authors show how irreverence may be a form of ethical seriousness, a protest against hypocrisy, and an enlivening source of renewal in a world that feels increasingly fragile. It is delightful to encounter a volume that makes one think harder while also allowing us to breathe easier. This one does just that, inviting us to consider irreverence but also to practice it as a mode of more complete encounter with each other and with the field of psychoanalysis itself.'

Tom Wooldridge, PsyD, ABPP, CEDS-C, Professor of Psychology at Golden Gate University, Personal and Supervising Analyst, Psychoanalytic Institute of Northern California (PINC), and Training Analyst, San Francisco Center for Psychoanalysis (SFCP).

'Irreverence may not win you many friends, but it remains essential to a creative and engaging

life in psychoanalysis. An irreverent approach is not the same as disrespect. One can value established methods, while also questioning their relevance—a dialectic that acknowledges history and precedent.  Today’s psychoanalysis too often splits itself into distinct sects, each claiming its own version of ultimate truth. Yet true irreverence resists this pull toward doctrinal certainty. Instead, it has the potential to invite us into mystery. Analysts are drawn to the experience of awe: the vastness of a star-filled sky, the hush of a cathedral, the paradoxes of quantum physics, the unfathomable nature of consciousness. These encounters with wonder may, paradoxically, carry greater therapeutic potential than the reverent pursuit of conventionally packaged theory.

Drs. Petrucelli and Schoen—two senior analysts and prolific authors— gather a set of stimulating and provocative essays that explore how irreverence engages psychoanalysis’ promise. I am delighted to endorse this work, which closely reflects my own perspective. It is a book that can expand one's outlook and make the analytic enterprise more exciting, more engaging, and ultimately more clinically effective.'

Edgar A. Levenson, MD, Fellow Emeritus, Training, Supervising Analyst, Faculty at the William Alanson White Institute; Winner of the 2006 Mary S. Sigourney Award, Author of over 110 publications, including Fallacy of Understanding (1972), The Ambiguity of Change (1983) and The Purloined Self (2016).

'What a delightful moment for subversion! Petrucelli and Schoen, editors of this wonderful text, invite us to venture beyond the safe and toward the quicksand that surrounds our psychoanalytic field, our country, and the world today. Feast on its riches and treat it like the Italian slow food movement, savor, rather than devour it.  And go back for another tasting menu tomorrow.'

Joyce Slochower, Ph.D., ABPP, Faculty NYU Postdoctoral Program in Psychotherapy and Psychoanalysis; Author of Psychoanalysis and the Unspoken (2024).

'From Freud’s era to the present, an irreverent aesthetic captures the best of what psychoanalysis has to offer—challenging orthodoxy, deconstructing norms, and questioning received wisdoms. In this important volume, Petrucelli and Schoen bring together a remarkable multiplicity of voices to deftly explore this territory, opening the space between tradition and innovation, past and present, the familiar and the strange. Prepare to be alternately destabilized, enticed, and provoked as these chapters transform what has often felt inevitable into a world of as yet to be imagined possibilities. A profound contribution to the field.'

Galit Atlas, Ph.D., Author of Emotional Inheritance, faculty NYU Postdoctoral Program for Psychotherapy and Psychoanalysis.