Rationality in Politics and its Limits  book cover
1st Edition

Rationality in Politics and its Limits

Edited By

Terry Nardin

ISBN 9781138306349
Published January 12, 2018 by Routledge
168 Pages

SAVE $16.49
was $54.95
USD $38.46

Prices & shipping based on shipping country


Book Description

The word ‘rationality’ and its cognates, like ‘reason’, have multiple contexts and connotations. Rational calculation can be contrasted with rational interpretation. There is the rationality of proof and of persuasion, of tradition and of the criticism of tradition. Rationalism (and rationalists) can be reasonable or unreasonable. Reason is sometimes distinguished from revelation, superstition, convention, prejudice, emotion, and chance, but all of these also involve reasoning. In politics, three views of rationality – economic, moral, and historical – have been especially important, often defining approaches to politics and political theory such as utilitarianism and rational choice theory. These approaches privilege positive or natural law, responsibilities, or human rights, and emphasize the importance of culture and tradition, and therefore meaning and context.

This book explores the understanding of rationality in politics and the relations between different approaches to rationality. Among the topics considered are the limits of rationality, the role of imagination and emotion in politics, the meaning of political realism, the nature of political judgment, and the relationship between theory and practice. This book was originally published as a special issue of Global Discourse.

Table of Contents

1. Introduction: Rationality in politics and its limits Terry Nardin

2. Political philosophy and the attraction of realism Paul Kelly

Reply - Realism and imagination: a response to Kelly Luke O’Sullivan

3. Hobbes and human irrationality Sandra Leonie Field

Reply - Sovereigns and citizens: a response to Field Luke O’Sullivan

4. Reason, statecraft and the art of war: a politique reassessment David Martin Jones

Reply - Morality and contingency: a response to Jones Jeremy Arnold

5. Thumos and rationality in Plato’s Republic Christina Tarnopolsky

Reply - Argument and imagination: a reply to Tarnopolsky Hui-Chieh Loy

6. ‘A habitual disposition to the good’: on reason, virtue and realism Adrian Pabst

Reply - Reason, faith and modernity: a response to Pabst William Bain

7. Oakeshott on theory and practice Terry Nardin

Reply - Oakeshott on the theory-practice problem: a reply to Terry Nardin Steven B. Smith

8. Franz Jägerstätter as social critic Peter D. Finn

Reply - The social critic and universal morality: a response to Finn Heather M. Roff

Reply - Reply to Roff Peter D. Finn

View More



Terry Nardin is Professor of Political Science at the National University of Singapore. He is the author of Law, Morality, and the Relations of States (1983) and The Philosophy of Michael Oakeshott (2001), and editor of Michael Oakeshott’s Cold War Liberalism (2014).