1st Edition

Russell vs. Meinong
The Legacy of "On Denoting"

ISBN 9780415808590
Published February 3, 2012 by Routledge
398 Pages

USD $62.95

Prices & shipping based on shipping country


Book Description

A century after ‘On Denoting’ was published, the debate it initiated continues to rage. On the one hand, there is a mass of new historical scholarship, about both Russell and Meinong, which has not circulated very far beyond specialist scholars. On the other hand, there are continuing problems and controversies concerning contemporary Russellian and Meinongian theories, many of them involving issues that simply did not occur to the original protagonists.  This work provides an overview of the latest historical scholarship on the two philosophers as well as detailed accounts of some of the problems facing the current incarnations of their theories.

Table of Contents

Introduction: Russell and Meinong in Retrospect  1. Logic and Denotation Alasdair Urquhart  2. Antirealism and the Theory of Descriptions Graham Stevens  3. Russell vs. Frege on Definite Descriptions as Singular Terms Francis Jeffry Pelletier and Bernard Linsky  4. A Cantorian Argument Against Frege’s and Early Russell’s Theories of Descriptions Kevin C. Klement  5. ‘On Denoting’: Appearance and Reality Gideon Makin  6. Explaining G. F. Stout’s Reaction to Russell’s ‘On Denoting’ Omar W. Nasim  7. Russell on ‘the’ in the Plural David Bostock  8. Psychological Content and Indeterminacy with Respect to Being: Two Notes on the Russell-Meinong Debate Johann Christian Marek  9. Meditations on Meinong’s Golden Mountain Dale Jacquette  10. Rethinking Item Theory Nicholas Griffin  11. Contra Meinong Peter Loptson  12. Who is Afraid of Imaginary Objects? Gabriele Contessa  13. Russell’s Definite Descriptions de re Gregory C. Landini  14. Quantifying in and Anti-Essentialism Michael Nelson  15. Points, Complexes, Complex Points, and a Yacht Nathan Salmon

View More



Nicholas Griffin is Director of the Bertrand Russell Centre at McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, where he holds a Canada Research Chair in Philosophy. He has written widely on Russell and is the general editor of The Collected Papers of Bertrand Russell, the author of Russell’s Idealist Apprenticeship, and the editor of The Cambridge Companion to Bertrand Russell, and two volumes of Russell’s Selected Letters.

Dale Jacquette is Senior Professorial Chair in Theoretical Philosophy at the University of Bern, Switzerland.  He has recently published Meinongian Logic: The Semantics of Existence and Nonexistence; Wittgenstein’s Thought in Transition; On Boole; Ontology; David Hume’s Critique of Infinity; and The Philosophy of Schopenhauer.