The Church at War: The Military Activities of Bishops, Abbots and Other Clergy in England, c. 900-1200
The fighting bishop or abbot is a familiar figure to medievalists and much of what is known of the military organization of England in this period is based on ecclesiastical evidence. Unfortunately the fighting cleric has generally been regarded as merely a baron in clerical dress and has consequently fallen into the gap between military and ecclesiastical history. This study addresses three main areas: which clergy engaged in military activity in England, why and when? By what means did they do so? And how did others understand and react to these activities? The book shows that, however vivid such characters as Odo of Bayeux might be in the historical imagination, there was no archetypal militant prelate. There was enormous variation in the character of the clergy that became involved in warfare, their circumstances, the means by which they pursued their military objectives and the way in which they were treated by contemporaries and described by chroniclers. An appreciation of the individual fighting cleric must be both thematically broad and keenly aware of his context. Such individuals cannot therefore be simply slotted into easy categories, even (or perhaps especially) when those categories are informed by contemporary polemic.
The implications of this study for our understanding of clerical identity are considerable, as the easy distinction between clerics acting in a secular or ecclesiastical capacity almost entirely breaks down and the legal structures of the period are shown to be almost as equivocal and idiosyncratic as the literary depictions. The implications for military history are equally striking as organisational structures are shown to be more temporary, fluid and 'political' than had previously been understood.
Table of Contents
Part 1: Occasions and Participants
Chapter 1: Fighting Clergy in Battle and on Campaign
Part 2: Military Power and Practice
Chapter 2: Prelates and their Warriors
Chapter 3: Prelates and their Fortresses
Chapter 4: Spiritual Weapons in Secular Warfare
Chapter 5: Delegated Powers and Marcher Lords
Part 3: Responses
Chapter 6: Canonical Responses
Chapter 7: Political and Judicial Responses
Chapter 8: Narrative Responses
Daniel M. G. Gerrard is Director of Greene's Institute in Oxford.
"As a resource to provide a useful framework for further research into the role of warrior clerics, it performs admirably." - Matthew Firth, University of New England