1st Edition
The Law and Regulation of Airspace Liberalisation in Brazil What is the Way Forward?
By Delphine Defossez
Copyright 2022
264 Pages
1 B/W Illustrations
by
Routledge
264 Pages
1 B/W Illustrations
by
Routledge
264 Pages
1 B/W Illustrations
by
Routledge
Also available as eBook on:
The book starts from the premise that the current aviation framework, in Brazil, cannot sustain a full liberalisation in the long run. While the competition rules in place offer a strong framework, which only requires small modifications, these rules are not "enough" to foster a "healthy" liberalisation. In fact, until recently, Brazilian airlines were operating in a homogenous market, where... Read more
CHAPTER 1 – Setting up the scene
- The Brazilian aviation landscape until 2019
- The two major challenges
- Liberalisation benefits for Brazil
- The role of the State in aviation
- Legitimatcy of state intervention and the Rule of law
- The thin line between regulation and competition
- Market failure in aviation and its liberalisation/deregulation
- Market failure and Natural monopolies
- Airports: natural monopolies or not?
- Concluding remarks
PART I- European liberalisation
CHAPTER 2 – Historical Perspective on Liberalisation of the Aviation Sector
- The changes in international aviation law: the road to liberalisation
- The European liberalisation
- The First Waves of Liberalisation in Europe
- An Integrated System: The Single European Sky (SES)
- Other models of liberalisation and their influence on the European model
- The US deregulation
- Comparison EU-US
- The US- EU Open Aviation Area
- The Asian liberalisation
- The ASEAN- EU Agreement
- The influence on Australia
- Concluding Remarks
CHAPTER 3 – The repercussions of the EU liberalisation
- The repercussions of the EU liberalisation
- Positive impacts
- Negative impacts
- The case of Alitalia (AZ)
- Competition advantages and (possible) problems
- Overview of competition rules applying under the EU system
- Airline companies
- More competition, yes, but not to the detriment of the security of passengers
- Consumer protection: Regulation 261/2004
- The problematic Regulation 261/2004
- Compensation for cancelled flights.
- Compensation for long delays.
- ‘Extraordinary circumstances’: the secret weapon of airlines
- Resolution 261 and international law
- Concluding Remarks
PART II- Brazil liberalisation
CHAPTER 4 – The Brazilian legal system
- Brief Overview of the legal system: hierarchy of norms
- The main organs in aviation
- The Brazilian legal system on aviation
- Laws applicable to aviation
- General aviation liability regulation
- Liability in case of collisions
- Consumer Protection: The Codigo de Proteçao e Defesa do Consumidor (CDC) vs the Montreal Convention
- The promising Projeto de Lei (PL) 6960 de 2010
- Lei 14.034/20 de 2020
- Consumer protection: ANAC
- Resolution 141/2010
- Cancellation
- Delay
- Extraordinary Circumstances
- Resolution 400/2016
- Competition law
- Concluding remarks
CHAPTER 5–The Brazilian national ‘liberalisation’
- Why liberalisation and not deregulation?
- ANAC’s perspective vs international understanding
- Why liberalise the Brazilian market?
- Bilateral agreements: an outdated concept?
- Concluding remarks
Chapter 6- Liberalisation of the national market: possible changes
- The current aspects of the Brazilian market: brief overview
- Economic effect
- Evolution of supply
- Changes in demand
- The routes
- Airline companies
- Hubbing
- New business models
- Low-Cost Carriers (LCCs) as game changers
- The need for product differentiation
- Higher risk of bankruptcy
- Airline privatisation
- Consolidated market and Avianca’s ‘bankruptcy’
- Airports
- Airport charges
- Increase in competition and airport saturation
- Major gain for regional airports
- Slots allocation
- The Role of the State
- Regional changes: Mercosur
- Concluding remarks
CHAPTER 7 – State intervention
- State intervention is still necessary
- State intervention after the potential liberalisation in Brazil
- Bilateralism and liberalisation
- Avianca’s tragedy and the role of the judiciary
- Market Regulation and State intervention
- Natural monopolies
- State aid
- Abuse of dominant position
- Codesharing and cartel formation
- Public interest element
- Consumers
- Self-regulation and Private ordering
- The GATT approach
- Concluding remarks
CHAPTER 8– Consumer protection
- Existing a solution
- The problems with the current system: irreconcilable judgments
- Theory vs Practice
- It is always the airline’s fault
- Brazil exorbitant jurisdiction: The NYE case
- The outrageous case: Valentine’s Day Lunch
- The totally irreconcilable judgments
- Two separate contracts? Make it just one
- Consumidor.com.gv
- The necessity to adapt the existing system and the use of Online Dispute Resolution (ODR) as a way forward
- Why Online Dispute Resolution?
- Collective redress and ODR
- Public authority rather than private actors
- Concluding remarks
Chapter 9- Conclusion
Biography
Delphine Defossez is Lecturer in Law at Northumbria University, UK






