The Making of a Police Officer
Comparative Perspectives on Police Education and Recruitment
Does a more academic type of police education produce new police officers that are reluctant to patrol the streets? What is the impact of gender diversity and political orientation on a police students’ career aspirations and attitudes to policing? These are some of the questions addressed by this longitudinal project, following police students in seven European countries. The unique data material makes it possible to explore a wide range of topics relevant to the future development of policing, police education and police science more generally.
Part I presents an overview of the different goals and models of police education in the seven participating countries. Part II describes what type of student is attracted to police education, taking into consideration educational background, political orientation and career aspirations. Part III shows the social impact of police education by examining students’ orientations towards emerging competence areas; students’ career aspirations; and students’ attitudes concerning trust, cynicism and legalism.
The overall results show that police students are strikingly similar across different types of police education. Students in academic institutions are at least as interested in street patrolling as students in vocational training institutions. Gender and recruitment policies matters more in relation to career preferences than education models. The national context plays a more important role than the type of police education system. Written in a clear and direct style, this book will appeal to students and scholars in policing, criminology, sociology, social theory and cultural studies and those interested in how police education shapes its graduates.
Table of Contents
Notes on contributors
Lists of figures
List of tables
List of contributors
Part I: Police education in seven European countries
- A longitudinal and comparative European Study of Recruitment, Education and Careers in the Police (RECPOL): What this project contributes to the development of police science
Tore Bjørgo and Marie-Louise Damen
- Police education in seven European countries in the framework of their police systems
- Diversity and academisation: who does police education attract?
- Iceland as a microcosm of the effects of educational reform on police students’ social background
- Mirroring society: how politically representative are police students in Europe?
- Understanding learning preferences and career aspirations of Norwegian police students from a comparative perspective
- Police students’ values of enduring and emerging competence areas in police education
- Horizontal and vertical career preferences and aspirations for male and female police recruits
- Cynicism and (dis)trust in the police: self-selection or evolving attitudes?
- Producing legalists or Dirty Harrys? Police education and field training
- Selecting and shaping police students in Europe: main findings and discussion
Kjersti Hove and Lola Vallès
Part II: Selecting police students
Rasmus Juul Møberg
Guðmundur Oddsson, Andrew Paul Hill, Ólafur Örn Bragason, Þóroddur Bjarnason and Kjartan Ólafsson
Pål Winnæss, Marie-Louise Damen and Gunnar Thomassen
Part III: Shaping police students
Staffan Karp, Kirsi Kohlström, Oscar Rantatalo and Mojgan Padyab
Rasmus Juul Møberg and Marie-Louise Damen
Gunnar Thomassen and Jon Strype
Silje Bringsrud Fekjær and Otto Petersson
Marie-Louise Damen and Tore Bjørgo
Tore Bjørgo is a professor at the University of Oslo and an adjunct professor of police science at the Norwegian Police University College. He is also director of the Center for Research on Extremism (C-REX). He initiated the RECPOL project in 2008 and has been leading it since the start until recently. He has published extensively in the fields of violent extremism and terrorism, criminal gangs, crime prevention, policing and vigilantism.
Marie-Louise Damen is an associate professor in quantitative research methods at the Norwegian Police University College in Oslo. Her research interests are sociology of higher education, stratification, cultural sociology, social movements and research methodology. Since October 2017 she has been involved in the RECPOL-project and has gradually taken over as coordinator.
The international and comparative research on police education and training described in this book offers fundamental empirical insights regarding an aspect of vital concern in police studies. Researchers and policy makers alike will find in this volume a wealth of information and detail that will provide insights into career entry and early professional socialization into the police organization in seven European countries. Original research of this kind practically demonstrates the important contribution of independent academic research on the public understanding of police institutions.
James Sheptycki, Professor of Criminology, York University, Canada
The book answers important questions about how to recruit and train police, and ways to nurture healthy perspectives among officers and launch successful careers in law enforcement. Sweeping across seven regions of the northern hemisphere, the research behind these findings and recommendations promises to be applicable to a broad variety of policing traditions. There is nothing else like it.
Wesley G. Skogan, Professor of Political Science, Institute for Policy Research, Northwestern University, USA
This book is an eye-opener for all those engaged in policing. The authors address the broader issues related to police recruitment, education and its academisation. Debunking widespread myths, they add essential nuances to its complexity and offer a research agenda for the future.
Marleen Easton, Professor Governing & Policing Security, Faculty of Economics and Business Administration, Ghent University
How can we ‘make’ police officers? What we need is a consistent democratic approach from recruitment to further education. But how can we neither produce Dirty Harrys nor Legalists? How can we implement the right philosophy of policing into police students? This study by a European group of police scholars provides us with substantial data and interpretation. A must read for police educators all over Europe.
Thomas Feltes, Senior professor in Criminology and Police Science, Ruhr-University Bochum, Germany