1st Edition
The Politics of Transdisciplinarity Collaboration and Control at the Interface of Science, Policy and Society
This book discusses collaborative research as both a product of social and epistemic control, and as a process of dealing with it. It offers fresh multi-disciplinary perspectives on old questions that are gaining new urgency with the rise of participatory, transdisciplinary and transformative research.
The volume addresses the complexity of collaborative research at the interface of science, policy and society and sheds light on a common dilemma: researchers and their collaborators tackling issues that require political and knowledge-based control. At the same time, collaborative research that involves diverse publics is difficult to predict or regulate. By examining the interplay of power and knowledge in these collaborations, the book offers insights into how researchers navigate the dilemma of social and epistemic control. This exploration is crucial for understanding the politics of transdisciplinarity. Featuring contributions from various fields including transdisciplinary sustainability studies, science and technology studies, policy analysis, participatory research and more, the book discusses different methodologies, practices, theories, and adaptations in response to the control dilemmas inherent in collaborative research to offer a deeper understanding of the nuanced relationship between power and knowledge within collaborative research.
The Politics of Transdisciplinarity will be a key resource for the reflexive researcher working with collaborative approaches at the interface of science, policy and society. It was originally published as a special issue of Social Epistemology.
Introduction: Social and Epistemic Control in Collaborative Research – Reconfiguring the Interplay of Politics and Methodology
Jeremias Herberg and Ulli Vilsmaier
1. The Limits of Epistemic Control, the Powers of Actualization, and the Moral Economies of a Fictional Collective
Judith Igelsböck
2. Untrol: Post-Truth and the New Normal of Post-Normal Science
Katharine N. Farrell
3. Designing a Transformative Epistemology of the Problematic: A Perspective for Transdisciplinary Sustainability Science
Esther Meyer and Daniela Peukert
4. Navigating between Complexity and Control in Transdisciplinary Problem Framing: Meaning Making as an Approach to Reflexive Integration
Basil Bornemann and Marius Christen
5. Knowledge Decolonization à la Grounded Theory: Control Juggling in Research Situations
Maria De Eguia Huerta
6. Identity Politics: Participatory Research and its Challenges Related to Social and Epistemic Control
Stefan Böschen, Martine Legris, Simon Pfersdorf and Bernd Carsten Stahl
7. The Phase Zero: Why Collaborative Research is Not Co-Designed but Scripted
Jeremias Herberg
Biography
Jeremias Herberg is a sociologist and practitioner at the interface of environmental politics and research. He heads the presidential department of the German Environment Agency and held a visiting professorship at Ruhr University Bochum. He publishes broadly on social dimensions of sustainability. He co-founded the Journal of Political Sociology.
Ulli Vilsmaier is a geographer by training and specialized in inter- and transdisciplinary research and higher education. Her research focuses on designing, accompanying, implementing and evaluating boundary-crossing research and on methods for boundary work and integration. She has significant international experiences with research development and transformations of academic institutions.
