1st Edition

The Rise of Comparative Policing

Edited By Jacques de Maillard, Sebastian Roché Copyright 2022
    158 Pages
    by Routledge

    158 Pages
    by Routledge

    This book argues that policing should be studied in a truly comparative manner as a way of identifying more accurately the diverse features of police organisations and the trends which affect contemporary policing. Studying policing comparatively is also a way to develop more sophisticated theories on the relations between police, state, and society aiming at higher degree of generalization. In particular, broadening the empirical basis, often limited to Western countries, favours the formulation of more encompassing theories. The comparative analysis, then, is used to refine meso or macro theories on various aspects of policing.

    The book covers the challenges of comparative research in diverse areas of policing studies with innovative tools and approaches to allow for the development of that subfield of policing. It is a significant new contribution to policing studies, and will be a great resource for academics, researchers, and advanced students of Public Policy, Sociology, Political Science and Law.

    The chapters in this book were originally published in Policing and Society.


    Challenges and promises of comparative policing research

    Jacques de Maillard and Sebastian Roché

    Policing and the state: national paradigms, private security and citizens’ role

    1. Plural policing, the public good, and the constitutional state: an international comparison of Austria and Canada – Ontario

    Bas van Stokkom and Jan Terpstra

    2. Comparing private security regulation in the European Union

    Mark Button and Peter Stiernstedt 

    3. Citizen participation in community safety: a comparative study of community policing in South Korea and the UK

    Kwan Choi and Ju-lak Lee

    Comparing police–citizen relations: policies and practices

    4. Under-regulated and unaccountable? Explaining variation in stop and search rates in Scotland, England and Wales

    Genevieve Lennon and Kath Murray

    5. Different styles of policing: discretionary power in street controls by the public police in France and Germany

    Jacques de Maillard, Daniela Hunold, Sebastian Roché and Dietrich Oberwittler 

    Police legitimacy, democracy and integrity: the need for comparative instruments across contexts

    6. Police legitimacy in Africa: a multilevel multinational analysis

    Francis D. Boateng

    7. Assessing the validity of police integrity scale in a comparative context

    Jon Maskály, Sanja Kutnjak Ivković, Maria Haberfeld, Christopher Donner, Tiffany Chen and Michael Meyers


    Jacques de Maillard is Professor of Political Science at the University of Versailles-Saint-Quentin and at Sciences Po Saint Germain-en-Laye, and director of the CESDIP (a research centre affiliated to the CNRS, the French Ministry of Justice, the University of Versailles-Saint-Quentin and CY Cergy Paris Université). His interests lie in the questions of local governance of security, the comparative study of policing in Western countries and plural policing.

    Sebastian Roché is CNRS (National Center for Scientific Research) Research Professor at Sciences Po / University of Grenoble Alpes, Pacte research unit. He is the European Editor of Policing and Society. He specializes in comparative governance of police systems and of policing practices.