1st Edition

What If? Thought Experimentation in Philosophy

Edited By Nicholas Rescher Copyright 2005
    190 Pages
    by Routledge

    189 Pages
    by Routledge

    Thought experimentation has been a staple of philosophical methodology since classical antiquity, when Xenophanes of Colophon speculated that if horses had gods, they would be equine in form. Nicholas Rescher's What If? undertakes a systematic survey of the role and utility of thought experiments in philosophy. After surveying the historical issues, Rescher examines the principles involved, and explains the conditions under which thought experimentation can validly yield instructive results in philosophy. The reader gains understanding of the differences between scientific and philosophical experiments.

    What If? begins by examining the nature of thought experiments. It presents an overview of how thought experiments have figured in natural science and in historical studies, before moving on to examine how they function as an instrument of philosophical inquiry. After examining thought experiments from the pre-Socratics to the present day, Rescher turns from history to analysis, and examines the modes of reasoning involved in the use of speculative hypotheses in philosophical problem solving. He shows the limitations of speculative ontology, showing that thought experimentation can lead readily to paradox in a way that increasingly diminishes its usefulness. The book concludes by arguing and illustrating how and when it becomes pointless to push speculation, or thought experimentation beyond the limits of intelligibility and cogent sense.

    Among the principal features of Rescher's book is its elaborate analysis of the appropriate conditions for philosophical thought experimentation. Its cardinal thesis is that there indeed are limits to the appropriateness of this important methodological resource and that transgressing these limits destroys the prospect of drawing any valid lessons for the philosophical enterprise. What If? will be of interest to philosophers, students of philosophy, and theorists of logic and reasoning.

    1: Thought Experimentation; 2: Thought Experimentation in Science and History; 3: Thought Experimentation in Philosophy; 4: Thought Experimentation in Pre-Socratic Philosophy; 5: Some Classic Philosophical Thought Experiments; 6: Aporetics and Cost-Benefit Analysis in Philosophical Thought Experimentation; 7: Issues of Speculative Ontology; 8: Philosophically Instructive Paradoxes; 9: Outlandish Hypotheses and the Limits of Thought Experimentation; 10: On Overdoing Thought Experimentation


    Nicholas Rescher