1st Edition

Justifying Punishment Perspectives from Post-Communist Europe

Edited By Jakub Drápal Copyright 2025
140 Pages 17 B/W Illustrations
by Routledge

140 Pages 17 B/W Illustrations
by Routledge

140 Pages 17 B/W Illustrations
by Routledge

This book develops principles of proper sentence justification, presents results of comparative empirical study on sentence justifications in the post-communist countries and provides practical measures to improve the current situation. Providing justification for sentences is an essential feature of any sentencing system that strives to achieve principled practice. Principled sentencing requires... Read more

List of contributors

Foreword

Acknowledgements

1. Introduction, Jakub Drápal

2. Reasons for (and against) justifying sentences, Jakub Drápal

3. Three Stages of Reason-Giving: Identification, Evaluation and Weighing, Pauline Schuyt, Jakub Drápal

4. Sentence justification in first-level courts in post-communist Europe, Jakub Drápal, Augustina Bolocan-Holban, Jaan Ginter, Mojca Plesničar, Kristýna Tomšů, Mihaela Vidaicu

5. Justifying Sentence Changes at Appellate Courts, Jakub Drápal, Tomáš Vanča

6. A Review of Sentence Justification: The case of the Netherlands, Sonja Meijer

7. Towards proper sentence justification, Jakub Drápal

Biography

Jakub Drápal is a researcher at the Institute of State and Law of the Czech Academy of Sciences, Czechia; an assistant professor at the Faculty of Law, Charles University, Czechia; and a MSCA-CZ fellow at Leiden University, the Netherlands.

"In addition to offering much-needed insight into sentencing policy and practice in Post-Communist Europe, this volume makes an important contribution to promoting better sentence justification. The chapters will be of interest to scholars and practitioners around the world."

Professor Julian V. Roberts, K.C. (Hon.), Oxford University

 

"This book provides the most valuable contribution to the discussion of judicial justifications of sentences in terms of the diagnosis of its nature, and proposals regarding proper approach to solving it."

Professor Krzysztof Krajewski, Jagiellonian University in Kraków