1st Edition

Using Debate in the Classroom Encouraging Critical Thinking, Communication, and Collaboration

    178 Pages
    by Routledge

    178 Pages
    by Routledge

    Debate holds enormous potential to build 21st century skills such as critical thinking, communication, collaboration, and conflict resolution in the K-12 classroom, but teachers often struggle to implement and contextualize it effectively. Using Debate in the Classroom draws on research from a variety of academic disciplines to explain the benefits of debate across subject areas, and describes how teachers can use debate to enliven their curriculum and support the aims of the Common Core. Topics include:

    • Introducing debate as a pedagogical practice to engage students, improve school culture, and disrupt the school to prison pipeline.
    • Using debate to teach critical literacy and improve students’ reading, writing, and speaking skills.
    • Implementing role-playing techniques to strengthen information literacy and reasoning skills.
    • Building students’ empathy, perspective-taking skills, and cultural humility as they confront difficult social issues through debate.

    Appendices provide a variety of tools to assist K-12 teachers in implementing debate in the classroom, including ready-made debate activities, student handouts, and a step-by-step guide to introducing students to debate in just one week.


    John Sexton


    Melissa Maxcy Wade


    An Introduction to Classroom Debate: A Tool for Educating Minds and Hearts

    Karyl A. Davis, M. Leslie Wade Zorwick, James Roland, and Melissa Maxcy Wade

    1. Take No Prisoners: The Role of Debate in a Liberatory Education

    Brittney Cooper

    2. Resolved: Debate Disrupts the School to Prison Pipeline

    Catherine Beane

    3. Evaluating Contradictory Evidence

    Jon Bruschke

    4. Making Words Matter: Critical Literacy, Debate, and a Pedagogy of Dialogue

    Susan Cridland-Hughes

    5. Discerning the Value of Information in the Digital Age

    Gordon Stables

    6. Engendering Academic Success: Debate as a School Engagement Strategy

    Carol Winkler

    7. Using Debate to Improve Scientific Reasoning

    Freddi-Jo Eisenberg Bruschke

    8. Critical Thinking through Debate: Skills, Dispositions, and Teaching Strategies

    W. Patrick Wade

    9. Using Debate to Develop Perspective Taking and Social Skills

    M. Leslie Wade Zorwick

    10. Creating Hospitable Communities: Remembering the Emanuel 9 as We Foster a Culture of Humility and Debate

    Ed Lee and Ajay Nair


    James Roland



    Karyl A. Davis directs communications for the Glenn Pelham Foundation for Debate Education and is the owner and principal creative of the consulting firm kd Alice Communications.

    M. Leslie Wade Zorwick is Associate Professor of Psychology at Hendrix College.

    James Roland is Senior Director of Community Programs and Engaged Scholarship at the Barkley Forum Center for Debate Education at Emory University.

    Melissa Maxcy Wade is President of the Glenn Pelham Foundation for Debate Education.



    "Using Debate in the Classroom proves that the art of evidence-based argumentation through debating can change a student's life. The authors take a deep and thoughtful approach to helping us better understand the necessity for the cross-curricular application of evidence-based argumentation. This book makes clear how debating can serve as a primary tool for students to gain the 21st century skills necessary to break down barriers, overcome challenges, and build the drive and motivation necessary for achievement." –J. Scott Wunn, Executive Director, National Speech and Debate Association

    “This is it -- an introduction to classroom debate that will forever change pedagogy! We learn in this volume that debate is for all disciplines, science to literature.  We learn that it is the antidote to socially mediated conformity and prejudice.  Critical thinking and social engagement in a poly-cultural environment is its outcome.  Moreover, the appendix is a ‘how-to’ manual for making it happen.  No one can read this book and not be transformed.” --E. Culpepper Clark, Dean Emeritus, Henry W. Grady College of Journalism and Mass Communication, University of Georgia