1st Edition

World Yearbook of Education 2012 Policy Borrowing and Lending in Education

Edited By Gita Steiner-Khamsi, Florian Waldow Copyright 2012
    464 Pages 11 B/W Illustrations
    by Routledge

    464 Pages 11 B/W Illustrations
    by Routledge

    The phenomenon of "travelling reforms" has become an object of great professional interest and intensive academic scrutiny. The fact that the same set of educational reforms is transferred from one country to another made scholars wonder whether policy transfer has increased as a result of globalization. But also the fact that policy makers increasingly import "best practices "and international standards and use them as a tool to accelerate reform has captured the imagination of many that deal with policy studies. An international comparative perspective is key for understanding why reforms travel from one corner of the world to another. Not surprisingly, the study of policy borrowing and lending constitutes one of the core research topics of comparative policy studies; a new area of research that links comparative education with policy studies.


    The World Yearbook of Education 2012 brings together a diverse range of perspectives on education policy through contributions from internationally renowned authors. It reflects on the way policy borrowing and lending is reconfiguring the world of education and offers a new collection of insights into the changes occurring across the world. It particularly focuses on:

      • The political and economic reasons for policy borrowing,
      • The agencies, international networks and regimes that instigate policy change,
      • The process of borrowing and lending
      • The impact of these systems, agendas and institutions on indigenous settings.

    This book will prove invaluable to researchers of globalization and to policy experts, especially those interested in comparative and international educational studies. It is also essential reading for undergraduate and postgraduate students and anyone involved in the sociology, economy or history of education.


    Gita Steiner-Khamsi is Professor of Comparative and International Education at Teachers College Columbia University, New York, US.

    Florian Waldow is Research Director at the University of Münster, Germany.


    Introduction   1. Understanding Policy Borrowing and Lending, Building Comparative Policy Studies Gita Steiner-Khamsi   Part 1. Agencies of Transfer   2. Toward a Critical Grammar of Education Policy Movements Roger Dale and Susan L. Robertson   3. Learning from Meetings and Comparison: A Critical Examination of the Policy Tools of Transnationals Sotiria Grek   4. Toward Post-Bureaucratic Modes of Governance: A European Perspective Christian Maroy   5. Educational Accountability and Global Governmentality Noah W. Sobe   6. Webs of Borrowing and Lending: Social Networks in Vocational Education in Republican China Barbara Schulte   Part 2. Externalisation and the Politics of Policy Borrowing and Lending   7. Reimagining Attraction and ‘Borrowing’ in Education: Introducing a Political Production Model Jeremy Rappleye     8. Bringing a Political ‘Bite’ to Educational Transfer Studies: Cultural Politics of PISA and the OECD in Japanese Education Reform Keita Takayama   9. International Benchmarking with the Best: The Varied Role of the State in the Quest for Regional Education Hubs in Malaysia and Hong Kong Ka Ho Mok   10. Policy Borrowing and the Rise of a Vocational Education and Training System: The Case of Switzerland Philipp Gonon   11. Education Policy Borrowing Across African Borders: Histories of Learner-Centred Education in Botswana and South Africa Linda Chisholm   Part 3. Selective Borrowing and the Local Adaptation of Imported Reforms   12. Contested Meanings of Educational Borrowing Iveta Silova   13. Teacher License Renewal System: Global and Local Influences on Teacher Accountability Policy in Japan Motoko Akiba and Kazuhiko Shimizu   14. The Transformation of Education Policy in Israel Julia Resnik   15. In the Shadow of Global Discourses: Gender, Education and Modernity in the Arabian Peninsula Natasha Ridge   16. Conditional Cash Transfers: Paying to Keep Children in School and Conquering the World. Three Selected Case Studies Michelle Morais de Sá e Silva   Part 4. Diffusion, Travelling Reforms and Policyscapes   17. Imagining Globalisation: Educational Policyscapes Stephen Carney   18. Policy Tourism and Policy Borrowing in Education: A Trans-Atlantic Case Study Geoff Whitty 19. Flowing Discourses and Border Crossing: The Slogan of ‘Respect for Diversity’ in Latin America Jason Beech and Emmanuel Lista   20. Facilitating Transfer: International Organisations as Central Nodes for Policy Diffusion Anja P. Jakobi   Conclusions   21. Standardisation and Legitimacy: Two Central Concepts in Research on Educational Borrowing and Lending Florian Waldow


    Gita Steiner-Khamsi is Professor of Comparative and International Education at Teachers College, Columbia University, New York, USA.

    Florian Waldow is Research Director at the University of Münster, Germany.

    'The 2012 World Yearbook of Education is a must-read, not only for scholars interested in global education policy, but also for anyone who wants to understand the scope and nature of educational change in the global era.' Antoni Verger, Comparative Education Review, 2013.

    'The book offers a comprehensive, insightful, and nuanced examination of education policy transformation in the global era and highlights the complexity of political, economic, and social contexts within which educational changes currently take place.' Antoni Verger, Comparative Education Review, 2013.