World Yearbook of Education 2014 Governing Knowledge: Comparison, Knowledge-Based Technologies and Expertise in the Regulation of Education
This latest volume in the World Yearbook of Education Series focuses on a major and highly significant development in the governing of education across the globe: the use of knowledge-based technologies as key policy sources. A combination of factors has produced this shift: first, the massive expansion of technological capacity signalled by the arrival of ‘big data’ that allows for the collection, circulation and processing of extensive system knowledge. The rise of data has been observed and discussed extensively, but its role in governing and the rise of comparison as a basis for action is now a determining practice in the field of education. Comparison provides the justification for ‘modernising’ policy in education, both in the developed and developing world, as national policy makers (selectively) seek templates of success from the high performers and demand solutions to apparent underperformance through the adoption of the policies favoured by the likes of Singapore, Finland and Korea.
In parallel, the growth of particular forms of expertise: the rise and rise of educational consultancy, the growth of private (for profit) involvement in provision of educational goods and services and the increasing consolidation of networks of influence in the promotion of ‘best practice’ are affecting policy decisions. Through these developments, the nature of knowledge is altered, along with the relationship between knowledge and politics. Knowledge in this context is co-constructed: it is not disciplinary knowledge, but knowledge that emerges in the sharing of experience.
This book provides a global snapshot of a changing educational world by giving detailed examples of a fundamental shift in the governing and practice of education learning by:
• Assessing approaches to the changing nature of comparative knowledge and information
• Tracking the translation and mobilisation of these knowledges in the governing of education/learning;
• Identification of the key experts and knowledge producers/circulators/translators and analysis of how best to understand their influence;
• Mapping of the global production of these knowledges in terms of their range and reach the interrelationships of actors and their effects in different national settings.
Drawing on material from around the world, the book brings together scholars from different backgrounds who provide a tapestry of examples of the global production and national reception and mediation of these knowledges and who show how change enters different national spaces and consider their effects in different national settings.
Part I Governing by Comparison 1. Comparative Research in Education: a mode of governance or a historical journey? Antonio Novoa and Tali Yariv-Mashal 2 Knowledge and governance in education: Steven J. Klees and D. Brent Edwards Jr 3. Network Alliances: Precarious Governance through Data, Standards and Code Tara Fenwick and Richard Edwards 4. The attraction of Mutual Surveillance of performance: PISA as a Knowledge-Policy Instrument: Luis Miguel Carvahlo Part 2 Knowledge Technologies in Action 5. Data Work: Michael Barber in conversation with Jenny Ozga 6. Networks of Influence in Higher Education Reform in Ethiopia: Tebeje Molla 7. Expert-Consultants and Knowledge production: Teachers for EFA in Brazil: Eneida Oto Shiroma 8. The Role of Knowledge in Scientific Policy Advice: Doing Knowledge Armin Nassehi and Alma Demsky and Armin Nassehi 9. Modernising education in Pakistan – network governance, the role of consultants and the prevalence of data: Sajid Ali 10. Big Data and the Politics of Education in Nigeria David Johnson 11. Understanding the Role of Feedback information in Flemish and European policy-making: Maarten Simons 12. National Qualifications Frameworks governing knowledge: insights from South Africa: Shirley Walter and Samuel Isaacs 13: Standardisation of professional knowledge and practice: The regulatory role of professional associations in Norway Monika Nerland & Berit Karseth 14. Governing Education in China: PISA, Comparison and Educational Regions Philip Wing Keung Chan and Terri Seddon 15. New Governing Experts in Education: Self-learning Software, Policy Labs and Transactional Pedagogies Ben Williamson