Impact and the Management Researcher
Universities, governments, faculty-evaluation committees, grant-bestowing institutions, scholars, and accreditation organizations have increasingly insisted on identifying and placing value on research impact. Valuation of research and scholarly output predicts innovation, affects careers, and guides resource allocations worldwide.
This book joins the burgeoning conversation in management and the social sciences with theoretical and applied discussions of the concepts, measurements, costs and benefits that accrue to pursuing scholarly impact. The author draws on a pioneering study by the Academy of Management that asked its global membership of 20,000 how they assessed scholarly impact, including rankings and impact factors, and how institutions supported this pursuit. Through qualitative and quantitative cross-country analysis by professorial rank, geographical region and support for various metrics, as well as exploration of parallel discussions in the social and hard sciences, the author argues for an urgent re-examination of the visible and invisible hands of research evaluation that shape lives and global societies.
The book presents original data on the external impacts of management research on policy, through the media, and in interest displayed by constituencies, which will make the book of interest to researchers, academics and students in the fields of business and management. Recommendations from leading management scholars and from the data follow for more valid, more reliable and less cynical metrics of research impact.
1. Measurement Matters (Usha C. V. Haley)
2. Why Study Scholarly Impact (Usha C. V. Haley)
3. Qualitative Data, Analysis & Results (Usha C. V. Haley)
4. Quantitative Data, Analysis & Results (Usha C. V. Haley & Melanie C. Page)
5. Global Differences in Measuring Scholarly Impact (Usha C. V. Haley & Melanie C. Page)
6. Focus on Latin America (José Luis Rivas)
7. Implications & Suggestions for Measuring Scholarly Impact (Usha C. V. Haley)
"A must-read for Business School Deans, all management scholars regardless of rank, and research managers alike … [this book] holds the potential to inform higher-education policy makers, as well as a broad range of practitioners who work closely with academics, aiding their insight into the contextual facets that influence and shape the delivery of impact in various scholarly domains around the world." Emily Yarrow, Academy of Management Learning & Education
"Since its establishment as an academic discipline, scholars in Management have been wracked by a core dilemma: How to gain legitimacy as a theory-grounded science while still staying relevant and having a practical impact? This book, and the ground-breaking research on which its based, tackles this dilemma head on. Beyond being required reading for Deans and T&P Committee members, the findings presented in this book deserve careful study by all those involved in and concerned with the future of management generally, and management education and research in particular." Peter A. Bamberger, Domberger Chair in Organization & Management, Tel Aviv University’s Coller School of Management, Israel and Research Director, Cornell University’s Smithers Institute, USA.
"An outstanding contribution ... the author, a very distinguished scholar, is leading the charge internationally to get business schools, government and funders to understand the importance of management research in terms of changing practice and policies rather than journal rankings of impact. This book is a must read by all Deans of business schools, university Presidents and funders of management research." Sir Cary L. Cooper, CBE, 50th Anniversary Professor of Organizational Psychology & Health, ALLIANCE Manchester Business School, University of Manchester, UK.
"A remarkable piece of scholarship. Written by a leader in the field, the book presents both original research and a concise survey of the key issues in achieving (or failing to achieve) impact in management research. A critical, practical and international book, this is a very significant publication for all of us who aspire to excellence and relevance in management research." Nic Beech, Vice-Chancellor, Middlesex University, UK and President of the British Academy of Management.